Sell Your Comic Book Collection – We Buy Comics!

Comic Book Collection Buyer for Golden, Silver, Bronze and Modern Age Comics

Free, no-obligation appraisal and written offer from comic book buyers since 1990.

  • Buying Comics Since 1990
  • 30+ Years of Experience
  • BBB A+ Rated
  • Insured Mail-In at Our Expense
  • Cash, Check, ACH or Wire

Get a Free Appraisal and Offer To Purchase Your Comic Book Collection

American Rarities buys comic book collections of every size — from a single key issue to long boxes and full estates. We have been buying comics since 1990. Most collector value sits in Platinum, Golden and Silver Age books; Bronze and Copper Age runs are more hit-or-miss, and modern comics are often bulk except for true keys. We buy the whole collection, not just the highlights, and we can submit comics for certification when it helps the sale.

For tips on getting top dollar, see how to sell your comics, selling comic books near you, or our guide on what makes a comic book valuable. Step-by-step: how to sell comic books.

We have been buying comics since 1990 and have purchased over $400 million in coins, comics and collections. To start, text a list or photos to 720-600-4740, email staff@americanrarities.com, or use the form below. You will get a free, no-obligation appraisal. All appraisal requests are reviewed in the order they are received. Some appraisals take minutes, while larger, more complex collections can take a few days. Either way, you’ll get a response from us.

Decorative gold separator bar

What We Buy

From a single key issue to a basement full of long boxes, we buy comics and related collectibles of every era. Collector value is usually strongest in Platinum through Silver Age books; we still buy Bronze, Copper and Modern Age collections, with modern often priced as bulk except for true keys.

CategoryExamples
Comic Books of Every AgeGolden, Silver, Bronze, Copper and Modern Age comics (see The Ages of Comic Books)
Key IssuesFirst appearances, origin stories, #1 issues and other key comics
Graded ComicsCGC, CBCS and PGX slabbed comics
Raw CollectionsUngraded collections, long boxes, full runs and complete sets
Original Comic ArtCover art, interior pages and newspaper comic strip art
PulpsVintage pulp magazines
Big Little BooksBig Little Books and similar small-format books
Fight Comics No. 82 comic book, Amazing Stories November 1928 pulp magazine and a Winsor McCay Little Nemo original ink drawing on a gold background
Decorative gold separator bar

Comic Book Dealers You Can Trust

Selling your prized comic book collection can be a big decision. You want to work with a company that understands the value of your comics and offers a secure, hassle-free experience. Here’s why American Rarities is the preferred choice for so many collectors: Prefer a buyer who comes to you? Learn how to sell comic books near you with a home or office visit.

  • Expert Evaluations: Our team has extensive experience in evaluating and appraising comic books. We understand the factors that influence value, such as rarity, condition, and historical significance, ensuring you receive a fair and accurate assessment.
  • Competitive Offers: We’re committed to offering competitive prices based on the current market value of your comic books, so you can be confident you’re getting a good deal.
  • Free and Easy Appraisals: Get a free appraisal without any obligation. Simply send us pictures or an inventory list, and our experts will provide a written appraisal of your collection’s worth.
  • Sell from Home with Our Secure Mail-In Service: Skip the hassle of traveling to a comic book store. Our fully insured mail-in service allows you to sell your comics safely and conveniently from home. Your shipment is fully insured at our expense, so you don’t have to worry about a thing.
  • Transparent and Fair Deals: With American Rarities, you get the full value of our written offer – no hidden fees, commissions, or deductions.
  • Fast and Easy Payment: Once you accept our offer, we’ll pay you promptly by your choice of cash, check, ACH or wire.

Comic collections often come with other collectibles. We also buy vintage toys and video games, including action figures, die-cast cars and classic Nintendo cartridges.

Decorative gold separator bar

Always Paying More for Your Rare Comics

Hands in white shirt sleeves counting cash between Golden Age comic books Startling Comics No. 2 (1940) and Cat-Man Comics No. 7 (1942) on a gold background

Sell Your Comic Collection in 5 Simple Steps

Free, no-obligation offers from comic book buyers since 1990.

  1. 1Send Photos and/or a List

    Smartphone with a light camera screen photographing Captain Marvel Adventures #18, with a handwritten My Comics inventory list

    Send clear photos of the front covers, or a list with title, issue number and publisher. Partial lists are fine. Use the form below, text 720-600-4740 or email staff@americanrarities.com.

  2. 2Free Appraisal and Written Offer

    American Rarities written appraisal and offer sheet listing Golden Age and Silver Age comic books with grades, with an Eschenbach 5X loupe

    An experienced comic book buyer reviews your collection and sends a free, no-obligation written offer. All appraisal requests are reviewed in the order they are received. Some appraisals take minutes, while larger, more complex collections can take a few days. Either way, you'll get a response from us.

  3. 3Ship Fully Insured

    Padlocked carton addressed to American Rarities, fully insured, with Whiz Comics #22 and Special Edition Comics #1 visible in a packing window

    If you accept, ship your comics fully insured at our expense, bagged and boarded and packed snugly so nothing moves. We do not provide shipping materials. If you decline, we return them fully insured.

  4. 4Meet in Person

    Our buyer examining Whiz Comics #2 with a seller, with Master Comics #12, Spy Smasher #2, Captain Midnight #1 and America's Greatest Comics #3 on the table

    For larger collections, a buyer from our nationwide network can meet you in person or arrange a home visit to go through long boxes with you.

  5. 5Get Paid

    Four ways to get paid for your comic books, stacked two by two: cash, check, ACH and wire

    Choose cash, check, ACH or wire. We pay immediately after your comics arrive or at the meeting.

Comic Book Selling Guides

Golden Age comic books Wings Comics No. 1, Planet Comics No. 5 and The Black Terror No. 11 fanned on gold, comics you can sell to American RaritiesSell My ComicsHow to get the best price for your collection
Golden Age comic books Captain Marvel Adventures #18 (1942) and Master Comics #16 (1941) side by side on a gold backgroundSell Comic Books Near MeHome visits and local comic buyers nationwide
The Amazing Spider-Man No. 122 and Superman No. 75 comic book coversBest Place to Sell Comic BooksWhat to look for in a comic book buyer
Golden Age comic book covers: Jumbo Comics, Jungle Comics, Fight Comics, Ghost Comics and Planet ComicsHow to Sell Comic BooksStep-by-step guide before you sell
Golden Age comic books Wings Comics No. 1, Planet Comics No. 5 and The Black Terror No. 11 fanned on gold, comics you can sell to American RaritiesGolden, Silver & Bronze AgesHow comic book ages affect value
Covers of vintage comic books, including Adventure Comics, The Amazing Spider-Man, Superman and Green LanternWhat Makes a Comic ValuableRarity, condition, keys and demand
Hands holding a stack of cash beneath three vintage Golden Age comic books: get your comics appraised by American RaritiesGolden Age Comics ValueHow to unlock top dollar for Golden Age books
Decorative gold separator bar

Free Appraisal for Your Comics and Comic Book Collections

Email, Text, or Use This Form To Send Us Your Inventory List or Pictures




Upload files of inventory lists and front and back photos of your items.

    We can help build your inventory list. Use the Collection List Maker to photograph your items and we'll build the inventory list for you.

    Decorative gold separator bar
    Fight Comics No. 77 raw and damaged beside the same Golden Age cover in a clear grading slab, showing how condition affects comic book value

    Appraising and Valuing Comic Books

    Our comic book buyers utilize all the tools available to appraise your comic book collection including recent auctions, current price listings, and other references. Key issues and first appearances bring the highest prices; see the top 5 rarest and most valuable Golden Age comic books.

    For more than 50 years, the Overstreet Comic Book Price Guide has been the bible for rarity and values. It is a necessary reference and belongs in every comic book collector’s toolbox.

    The Ages of Comic Books

    Age of Comic BooksYears
    Victorian Age1823 to 1932
    Platinum Age1933 to 1940
    Golden Age1938 to 1956
    Silver Age1956 to 1970
    Bronze Age1970 to 1984
    Copper Age1984 to 1991
    Modern Age1992 on

    Dates are approximate; collectors and price guides draw the lines a little differently.

    Decorative gold separator bar

    Comic Book Grading Services

    The high monetary value of many comic books necessitates third party grading services that will authenticate and grade them. The fee for getting a comic book graded is usually well worth the expense as it provides comic book collectors and comic book dealers the confidence they need to be sure that they are making good decisions when buying or selling them. The best of those grading services are shown below.

    CBCS Comic Book Certification Service comic book grading logo

    CBCS – Comic Book Certification Service (stopped taking new submissions on April 17, 2026; we still buy CBCS-graded comics)

    White cardboard comic book storage box filled with vintage comics in clear bags with backing boards, on a gold background

    Grading and Storing Your Valuable Comic Book Collection


    Proper grading and storage protect your comic book collection. The grade or quality of your comic book is an essential ingredient in determining its value. Knowing how to take care of your comic books is necessary as well.

    Decorative gold separator bar

    Comic Book Grading Scale

    The comic book grading scale is a 10-point system. It is far easier to understand than other collectible grading systems, such as the 70-point scale used for rare coins. Here is a link to a more descriptive list of the comic book grading scale definitions.

    GradeDescription
    10Gem Mint (GM)
    9.9Mint (MT)
    9.8Near Mint/Mint (NM/MT)
    9.6Near Mint+ (NM+)
    9.4Near Mint (NM)
    9.2Near Mint- (NM-)
    9.0Very Fine/Near Mint (VF/NM)
    8.5Very Fine+ (VF+)
    8.0Very Fine (VF)
    7.5Very Fine- (VF-)
    7.0Fine/Very Fine (FN/VF)
    6.5Fine+ (FN+)
    6.0Fine (FN)
    5.5Fine- (FN-)
    5.0Very Good/Fine (VG/FN)
    4.5Very Good+ (VG+)
    4.0Very Good (VG)
    3.5Very Good- (VG-)
    3.0Good/Very Good (GD/VG)
    2.5Good+ (GD+)
    2.0Good (GD)
    1.8Good- (GD-)
    1.5Fair/Good (FR/GD)
    1.0Fair (FR)
    0.5Poor (PR)
    Decorative gold separator bar

    Comic Book Selling FAQ

    Will you buy my whole comic collection, including common issues?

    Yes. We make one offer on the whole collection, from long boxes of reader copies and runs to key issues and graded slabs, so you do not have to sort out the valuable books first. If you prefer to keep some books, we can price the collection itemized so you can decide what to sell.

    Do my comics need to be graded before I sell?

    No. We buy both raw (ungraded) and graded comics, including CGC, CBCS and PGX slabs. You do not need to pay for grading before you get an offer. Grading only makes sense for key issues and high-grade books, and we can tell you which of yours, if any, are worth submitting.

    What kinds of comics and collectibles do you buy?

    We buy Golden, Silver, Bronze, Copper and Modern Age comics, key issues and first appearances, graded slabs, raw collections, long boxes and runs, original comic art, pulps and Big Little Books. We can include related collectibles in the same offer.

    How do I get a free appraisal?

    Use the appraisal form on this page, text photos to 720-600-4740, or email staff@americanrarities.com. Include clear photos of the front and back, or a list with title, issue number and publisher. Appraisals are free, with no obligation, and are All appraisal requests are reviewed in the order they are received. Some appraisals take minutes, while larger, more complex collections can take a few days. Either way, you'll get a response from us.

    Can I mail my comics to you?

    Yes. Our mail-in service is fully insured at our expense. Bag and board each book, pack them snugly so nothing shifts and use a sturdy box of your own, since we do not provide shipping materials. For large collections, a buyer can visit you in person instead.

    How will I be paid?

    Once you accept our offer, we pay immediately by cash, check, ACH or wire. You get a written offer first, with no obligation to sell, and if you decline after mailing your comics, we return them fully insured.

    Decorative gold separator bar

    Professional Associations

    Comic book grading company logos: CBCS, CGC, Midwest Comic Grading, Vault, EGS and PGX