Sell Rare U.S. Coins: Early American, Key Dates, Silver Dollars and Gold

Rare U.S. coins we buy: a 1798 Draped Bust dollar, 1793 large cent, Lincoln cent, 1899 $20 Liberty gold, 1921 Morgan dollar, 1907 Indian Head $10 and 1796 quarter on a gold background
Since 1990 buying coins$400 million+ purchasedA+ BBB rating4.7★ Google ratingAuthorized PCGS, NGC & ANACS dealerANA Life Members

Get a Free Appraisal and Offer on Your Rare U.S. Coins

From a worn 1793 large cent to a gleaming Morgan silver dollar or a pre-1933 $20 gold piece, United States coins are some of the most widely collected coins in the world. That demand is what makes rare U.S. coins valuable, and it is why the right buyer matters. A shop that prices by metal weight can miss a key date, a scarce mint mark or a premium grade.

American Rarities specializes in rare U.S. coins and has bought coins since 1990, with more than $400 million in purchases, an A+ rating from the Better Business Bureau and a 4.7-star average from 86 Google reviews. Every free appraisal comes with a no-obligation offer, and there is never any pressure to sell.

Looking for something else? To sell just one special coin, see Sell a Rare Coin. For a whole or inherited collection, see Sell My Rare Coins. For type sets, albums and commemoratives, see Sell Collector Coins. Selling a very large collection? See Sell a Large Coin Collection. We also buy gold and silver bullion and U.S. paper money (see our U.S. paper currency information). Wondering where to sell locally? See Where to Sell Coins Near Me.

Rare U.S. Coins We Buy

Rare U.S. coins we buy, from an Indian Head cent and Lincoln wheat cent through Buffalo nickel, Mercury and Barber dimes, Washington quarter, Walking Liberty half, Morgan and Peace dollars to Indian Head $10 and Saint-Gaudens $20 gold

We buy every series struck by the United States Mint, from the first coins authorized by the Coinage Act of 1792 to modern rarities. These are the U.S. coins we see most often and pay strong premiums for:

Want a rough idea first? Compare your coins with the NGC U.S. coin price guide, PCGS CoinFacts or the Smithsonian’s National Numismatic Collection, or browse our rare coins value list. Prices for rare dates change with grade, so a free expert appraisal is the surest way to know.

Decorative gold separator bar

Sell PCGS, NGC, ANACS and CAC Certified Coins

American Rarities is an authorized PCGS, NGC and ANACS dealer, so we know certified coins inside and out. We buy U.S. coins in every major holder, and we pay strong premiums for coins with a green CAC sticker, which shows the Certified Acceptance Corporation agrees the coin is solid for its grade.

  • Slabbed coins: send the certification number and a clear photo of the holder and we can price most coins quickly.
  • Raw coins: we grade them free in-house and tell you if submitting to PCGS or NGC would add enough value to be worth it. We can submit for you.
  • Older holders: early PCGS “rattler” and NGC “fatty” holders can bring extra premiums from collectors.

See more on how to sell PCGS, NGC and ANACS coins.

1884 Morgan silver dollar graded PCGS MS65 in a PCGS holder1890-CC Liberty Head $20 gold double eagle graded NGC AU58 in an NGC holder1925 Peace silver dollar graded ANACS MS64 in an ANACS holder

PCGS, NGC and ANACS holders

PCGS graded Morgan silver dollars with green CAC stickers in a dealer case

Green CAC stickers on PCGS Morgan dollars

Key Dates and Error Coins to Look For

A single key date or mint error can be worth more than the rest of a collection. Check your coins for these before you sell, then send photos for a free appraisal.

CoinWhat to look forWhy it is valuable
1909-S VDB Lincoln centS mint mark under the date, VDB initials at the bottom of the reverseOnly 484,000 struck
1914-D Lincoln centD mint mark under the dateAbout 1.2 million struck, few in high grade
1955 Doubled Die Lincoln centClear doubling in the date and LIBERTYFamous mint error variety
1916-D Mercury dimeD mint mark on the reverse, left of the fascesOnly 264,000 struck
1932-D and 1932-S Washington quartersD or S mint mark on the reverse below the eagleThe two lowest-mintage regular Washington quarters
1937-D “3-Legged” Buffalo nickelThe buffalo has only three legsDie polishing error
1889-CC and 1893-S Morgan dollarsCC or S mint mark below the wreath on the reverseLow mintages: 350,000 and 100,000
Mint errorsOff-center strikes, double strikes, wrong planchets, broadstrikesDramatic errors are scarce and collected

See our guides to error and variety coins and the rare coins value list.

Decorative gold separator bar

Why Sell Rare U.S. Coins to American Rarities

Hands counting cash between a 1795 Flowing Hair dollar, early U.S. gold coins, an 1873 Seated Liberty dollar and a 1921 Peace dollar
  • No one pays you more: we have bought coins since 1990, more than $400 million in purchases, and we pay for the collector value, not just the metal.
  • U.S. coin specialists: our buyers study American series every day and know the dates, mint marks, die varieties and grades that move a coin from common to rare. We use XRF metal testing and digital microscopy when needed.
  • Every coin gets an offer: large collection or small, we make an offer on every coin you show us, not just the few best pieces.
  • Graded or raw: an authorized PCGS, NGC and ANACS dealer, and we give raw coins a free in-house grade.
  • No fees, no obligation: no appraisal, listing or auction fees, and no obligation to accept our offer. We reply quickly. Timing depends on the size of your list, and we review submissions in the order we receive them.
  • Paid right away: once you accept, we pay immediately by cash, check, ACH or wire.
  • Trusted: A+ BBB rating, a 4.7-star Google rating, and Life Members of the American Numismatic Association.
Decorative gold separator bar

How to Sell Rare U.S. Coins in 5 Steps

  1. Smartphone camera with a light screen photographing an 1838-O Seated Liberty dime, slightly over a handwritten list of rare U.S. coins such as a Flying Eagle cent, Liberty nickel and Peace dollar

    1Send Photos and/or a List

    Use the form on this page, text 720-600-4740 or email staff@americanrarities.com. Photos of both sides of your key coins, a list of dates, mint marks and grades, or both, are plenty to start.

  2. American Rarities written appraisal and offer sheet listing rare U.S. coins such as an 1838-O Seated Liberty dime, an 1858 Flying Eagle cent and a 1921 Peace dollar, with an Eschenbach 5X loupe

    2Free Appraisal and Written Offer

    A U.S. coin specialist checks dates, mint marks, varieties and grades, then sends a free written, no-obligation offer. All appraisal requests are reviewed in the order they are received. Some appraisals take minutes, while larger, more complex collections can take a few days. Either way, you'll get a response from us.

  3. A taped, padlocked carton addressed to American Rarities and marked fully insured, beside a white delivery van

    3Ship Fully Insured, Paid by Us

    Ship your coins fully insured at our expense, with no deductible (use your own sturdy box; we do not provide shipping materials). If you decline, we return your coins fully insured.

  4. Our buyer examines an 1858 Flying Eagle cent with a loupe while a customer watches, with a 1921 Peace dollar, an 1883 Liberty nickel, an 1860 Indian Head cent and an 1892 Barber dime on the table

    4Or Meet a Buyer in Person

    For larger collections, a buyer can meet you at your home or office, or we can meet you at your bank. See if we have a rare coin buyer near you.

  5. Payment options for rare U.S. coins labeled cash, check, and ACH and wire: a banded stack of hundred-dollar bills, an American Rarities check and a bank-to-bank transfer

    5Get Paid Immediately

    Accept the offer and get paid immediately by cash, check, ACH or wire.

Selling an Estate or Inherited Coin Collection?

Executors, heirs, attorneys and CPAs trust American Rarities to value and buy inherited U.S. coin collections. We provide IRS-compliant estate appraisals, make one offer for the whole collection, and for large estates a buyer can meet you in person at your home, office or bank. There is never any obligation, and we can explain what each coin is worth so every heir understands the offer.

Decorative gold separator bar

Rare U.S. Coin Questions

Which U.S. coins are the most valuable?

The most valuable U.S. coins are early American coins, key dates, scarce mint marks and pre-1933 gold in high grades. Examples include early copper and silver from the 1790s, the 1909-S VDB and 1914-D Lincoln cents, the 1877 Indian cent, the 1916-D Mercury dime, the 1893-S Morgan dollar and Carson City gold. Date, mint mark and grade matter most, and a single grade point can change value a lot, so send photos for a free appraisal.

Is my old silver dollar worth more than its silver?

Often, yes. Morgan and Peace dollars contain about 0.7734 ounces of silver, but many sell for well above that because of their date, mint mark or condition. Uncirculated coins, Carson City dollars, key dates and prooflike coins carry strong premiums, and even common circulated dates usually bring a little over melt. We pay for the collector value, not just the metal.

Do you buy U.S. coins that are not graded?

Yes. Most of the coins we buy are raw, meaning not in a grading holder. Our specialists grade raw coins for free and tell you if PCGS or NGC grading would add enough value to be worth the fee. You never have to get coins graded before selling to us, and we also buy coins already certified by PCGS, NGC and ANACS.

Do you pay more for CAC-stickered coins?

Yes. A green CAC sticker means the Certified Acceptance Corporation reviewed a PCGS or NGC coin and judged it solid for its grade, and a gold sticker means it judged the coin stronger than its grade. Stickered coins usually bring a premium over the same grade without one, and the premium is largest on higher-value classic U.S. coins. We buy coins in all major holders, with or without stickers.

Where is the best place to sell rare coins near me?

The best place is a buyer with deep rare coin expertise, not necessarily the closest shop. A general shop that prices by metal weight can miss a key date or premium grade. You can get an expert appraisal from home by sending photos, then ship fully insured at our expense or, for larger collections, meet one of our buyers at your home or bank. Compare written offers, and check a buyer’s years in business, BBB rating and reviews.

How do I ship my coins to you?

Use our fully insured mail-in service at our expense, after you have our written offer. Pack your coins in your own sturdy box or padded mailer; we do not provide shipping materials. Keep coins in their holders, fill empty space so nothing shifts, and keep a copy of your list. We pay immediately when your coins arrive, and if you decline, we return your items fully insured. For large collections, a buyer can also meet you in person.

Do you buy inherited collections and estates?

Yes. We buy whole estates and provide IRS-compliant estate appraisals for executors and heirs, with no obligation to sell. Heirs do not need to sort or identify anything first: a few photos and a rough list are enough to start. Keep coins as you found them, since old albums, rolls and receipts can help with identification and value. See our guide on how to sell inherited coins.

Decorative gold separator bar

Free Appraisal for Your U.S. Rare Coins

Text, Email or Use This Form To Send Us Your Inventory List or Pictures

Use the form below, text 720-600-4740 or email staff@americanrarities.com




Upload files of inventory lists and front and back photos of your items.

    We can help build your inventory list. Use the Collection List Maker to photograph your items and we'll build the inventory list for you.

    Decorative gold separator bar

    Professional Associations

    Professional association and grading-service logos including ANA Life Member, PMG, PCGS, NGC, ANACS, CAC, CCE and currency-grading organizations