Services for Coin Dealers: We Buy Dealer Inventory, Bulk Lots and Referred Collections

Mixed dealer inventory of U.S. coins: a 1908 Saint-Gaudens $20, 1875-S Trade dollar, 1850 Seated dollar, $10 and $3 gold, Barber and Walking Liberty halves, Buffalo nickel, Mercury dime and Indian cent

American Rarities Is the Coin Dealer's Coin Dealer

American Rarities works with vest-pocket dealers, coin shops and full-time rare coin dealers nationwide. We are generalists: we buy U.S. and world coins, U.S. gold, certified and raw coins, and we put our capital, client base and expertise to work for other dealers. When you buy a collection that is bigger, more valuable or more specialized than your customers want, we give you a fast wholesale outlet.

We have bought coins since 1990, with more than $400 million in purchases, and American Rarities is a PCGS and NGC authorized dealer with an A+ rating from the Better Business Bureau. Our buyers can travel to your shop for larger purchases.

Not a dealer? Collectors and families should start with Sell a Rare Coin, Sell Rare U.S. Coins, Sell My Rare Coins or Sell Collector Coins. Buyers, salespeople and referrers can also see other ways to make money with rare coins.

Decorative gold separator bar

Wholesale Liquidity for Coin Shops and Vest-Pocket Dealers

Every dealer buys collections that include material with no immediate retail buyer: a run of high-grade type coins, a group of early gold, a box of certified world coins, or simply more inventory than your cash flow can carry. We buy that material so you can pay your seller, keep your capital working and move on to the next deal.

Because we sell to a large network of collectors and investors, we know where each coin brings the highest price, and that lets us make strong wholesale offers. You will get an offer on every coin, not just the best few, and our buyers are ready to travel to you for large purchases.

Decorative gold separator bar

Why Coin Dealers Sell to American Rarities

Hands in white shirt sleeves counting cash - fast payment services for coin dealers
  • Immediate payment: once we agree on a price, we pay right away by company check, wire or ACH.
  • Certified or raw: we buy coins graded by PCGS, NGC and ANACS and raw coins, and our specialists can authenticate questionable pieces in house.
  • Any size: from one rare coin to a large collection.
  • Clean paperwork: every purchase is documented, leaving a clear record for both sides; see the IRS rules on reporting cash payments over $10,000.

Grading standards drive wholesale pricing, so we work from the same references you do: the NGC grading scale, the NGC U.S. coin price guide and PCGS CoinFacts. For a refresher on how the services differ, read our guide to PCGS, NGC and ANACS.

Decorative gold separator bar

We Buy Dealer Inventories, Bulk Lots and Excess Numismatic Inventory

We buy full and partial shop inventories, bulk lots and dealer collections. If you are retiring, closing a shop, leaving the coin business or just need to raise cash, our buyers are ready to make you an offer on part or all of your inventory, from certified rarities and U.S. gold coins to bulk circulated coins, rolls and proof sets.

Large inventories are what we do every day. Read more about how we buy large coin collections, and see our page on GSA Carson City Morgan dollars.

Collection Referrals for Coin Dealers

Send us an estate or collection you cannot or do not want to buy yourself, and we pay you a referral fee of 15% of our profit. You also get first pick of the material: you can buy any coins you want for your own inventory before we offer them to our other clients. We give complete transparency on every referral transaction.

Why refer a collection to us? Many estates need more than an offer. We provide the appraisals your customers and their attorneys ask for:

  • Insurance and replacement value appraisals
  • Fair market value and liquid value appraisals
  • Date-of-death estate appraisals for heirs, executors and attorneys

We also work with professionals who advise those estates; see our page for estate planners.

Decorative gold separator bar

We Purchase Rare Coin Leads

American Rarities buys rare coin leads that help us find collections to purchase. Leads we buy include, but are not limited to:

  • Old coin company records
  • Client lists
  • Company mailing lists
  • Old invoice records
  • Numismatic client records

Coin Dealer Questions

What is a vest-pocket dealer?

A vest-pocket dealer is a part-time or independent coin dealer who buys and sells without a retail shop, usually working from home, by appointment, online or at coin shows. Many vest-pocket dealers buy collections larger than their own customers can absorb, which is where a wholesale outlet like American Rarities helps: we buy the material so you can pay your seller and keep your capital working.

Do I have to buy any coins myself to earn a referral fee?

No. The fee, 15% of our profit, is paid on collections you send us that you cannot or do not want to buy yourself. Taking coins with your first pick is optional: you can buy any coins you want for your own inventory before we offer them to our other clients. We give complete transparency on every referral transaction.

Can I sell you only the coins I can’t retail and keep the rest?

Yes. Send just the coins, lots or sets you have no buyers for and keep the rest for your own customers. We make an offer on every coin you send, certified or raw, from one rare coin to a full shop inventory. If you are retiring or closing a shop, we can also make an offer on part or all of your inventory.

Do you buy coin leads?

Yes. We buy rare coin leads that help us find collections to purchase, including old coin company records, client lists, company mailing lists, old invoice records and numismatic client records. Confidentiality is guaranteed. Email staff@americanrarities.com or text 720-600-4740 to describe what you have.

How fast do you pay coin dealers?

All appraisal requests are reviewed in the order they are received. Some appraisals take minutes, while larger, more complex collections can take a few days. Either way, you’ll get a response from us. Once we agree on a price, we pay right away by company check, wire or ACH, and every purchase is documented for both sides.

Decorative gold separator bar

Your Confidentiality is Guaranteed

Email, Text, or Use This Form To Send Us Your Inventory List or Pictures



Upload files of inventory lists and front and back photos of your items.

    We can help build your inventory list. Use the Collection List Maker to photograph your items and we'll build the inventory list for you.

    Decorative gold separator bar

    Professional Associations

    Professional association and grading-service logos including ANA Life Member, PMG, PCGS, NGC, ANACS, CAC, CCE and currency-grading organizations