We Buy Rare Coins, Gold & Silver Bullion, and U.S. Paper Currency
BBB A+ Rated
ANA Life Members- Fully Insured Mail-In
- Over 30 Years Buying Coins
- Over $400 Million Purchased
★★★★★ Read our Google reviews
“Very Professional and easy to sell your entire collection to. I was very impressed with the quickness of which I was paid as well. … I would highly recommend and would not hesitate to use them again.”
“… I received an initial offer in two days and it was more than fair. I followed their shipping instructions and received payment one day after they received my shipment. Very easy and honest to deal with. …”
“… My representative, David, was professional and maintained communication on a regular basis throughout the transaction. … I was kept informed as soon as my coins arrived and the check was sent on the same day. …”
Get a No-Obligation, Hassle-Free Appraisal and Offer
We regularly purchase American rare coins, foreign coins, U.S. paper currency, and bullion material from private coin collectors across the country. We buy rare coin collections of all types and sizes, and offer free appraisals on all collections our buyers examine for purchase.
Being a professional numismatic dealer, our staff works hard to make the strongest offer possible on every collection we evaluate. Unlike other buyers, we do not “cherry pick” collections. Our reputable buyers are interested in the most common and mundane coins, as well as the rarest and most esoteric pieces.
If you’re considering selling your coin collection, gold and silver bullion or paper currency, or even just want to know what your rare coin values are, contact an American Rarities specialist today.
We Pay More For Your Foreign and U.S. Rare Coins
Don’t sell your American coin or foreign coin collection for less than it is worth.
Our expert coin buyers are ready to pay you top dollar for your rare coins.
As a rare coin dealer, we are constantly looking to buy from coin collectors to meet our clients’ rare coin needs. To facilitate this, we provide free appraisals for all rare coin collections we inspect for potential purchase. We are interested in all coins with extra collectible or bullion value; US and world, ancient and modern, common or rare. Our expert buyers are ready to view your coin collection and make you an immediate, no-obligation offer.
Our Rare Coin Buyers Purchase:
Sell Your Collection in 3 Simple Steps
Free, no-obligation offers from a buyer with 30+ years of experience.
or
1Send Photos and/or an Inventory List
Snap a few phone photos, send a simple list, or both. Partial lists are fine. Use the form below or text them to 720-600-4740.
2Get a Free Written Offer
An experienced buyer reviews your coins and sends a free written offer. There is no obligation and no pressure to sell.
3Get Paid Fast
Accept and choose cash, check, or ACH/wire. Insured mail-in is at our expense, and for large collections a buyer can visit you in person.
Free · No obligation · Fully insured · 30+ years of experience
Why Sellers Trust American Rarities
ANA Life MembersAmerican Numismatic Association
BBB A+ RatedAccredited businessWhat We Buy
We buy a wide range of numismatic and bullion items, including:
- Rare Coin Collections: We purchase rare coin collections of all types and sizes. From individual rare coins to complete sets, we’re interested in items with extra collectible or bullion value.
- U.S. Rare Coins: This includes early American coins, gold coins, silver dollars, proof coins, and more.
- Silver Dollars: We buy Morgan, Peace, Carson City GSA, Trade, Seated Liberty and early silver dollars, from single coins to rolls and bags.
- Foreign Rare Coins: We buy rare coins from around the world, including ancient coins, European coins, and Asian coins.
- Certified Coins: We purchase authenticated coins graded by PCGS, NGC, ANACS, and other reputable grading services. You can verify a certified coin with the PCGS cert lookup or the NGC cert lookup.
- U.S. Paper Currency: We buy old paper money, including large size notes, small size notes, and Confederate currency.
- Gold & Silver Bullion: We buy gold and silver bars, rounds, and coins in various sizes and formats.
- U.S. Mint Sets & Proof Sets: We purchase modern U.S. Mint products, including proof sets, mint sets, and commemorative coins.
Our Buying Process
How We Establish The Value of Rare Coin Collections
The first step of getting an appraisal and offer is to provide us with information about your collection. It’s as easy as using the form below, texting photos to 720-600-4740, or emailing an inventory list (partial lists are fine) or photos of your coins to staff@americanrarities.com. One of our expert buyers will follow up with you with any questions we may have or further information we need. The buyer will then establish values, using all available resources to ensure accuracy, and give you a written appraisal and offer.
Upon your acceptance, we can arrange the best way to purchase the collection. This is either a personal meeting with one of our reputable buyers near you, or utilizing our convenient, fully insured Mail-In Service. In either case, you can count on a competitive offer for your numismatic items. Our private coin collector clientele want your rare coins.
Personal Visit
In many cases, we have a rare coin buyer near you. Our buyers regularly travel attending coin shows, as well as appraising and purchasing collections from private coin collectors just like you. The collection does not need to be organized or presented in any particular manner, we will examine every coin, album, or set in turn, in whatever order they may be in. Once our coin appraisal is complete, we will send you a written offer. Appraisals are usually done within 24 hours; larger collections can take a week or more, and we handle them in the order received. Have a large collection? Learn how we buy large coin collections, or see our local coin buyer and appraisal page.
Insured Mail-In Service
It is not always possible to visit everyone who has coins to sell. Some coin collections are too small to warrant a visit, or in other cases the travel expense is prohibitive. To address this issue, American Rarities offers a fully insured mail-in service. You can ship your coins directly to our buyer’s office, fully insured (at our expense). Immediate payment is customary, and if you decide not to sell, we will return your collection at our expense.
Inherited a Collection?
If you are settling an estate or have inherited coins, we can help you understand what you have before you decide anything. Read our guide on how to sell an inherited coin collection, learn about our estate appraisals and liquidation services, or share our page for the probate and estate lawyer with your attorney. Executors and families can start by sending photos through the form below, by text to 720-600-4740, or by email to staff@americanrarities.com.
Coin Value Guides & Resources
How to Sell a Coin CollectionFrom sorting and photos to a written offer
How to Sell Paper CurrencyFive steps to take before you sell your notes
How to Sell Gold CoinsKnow what your gold coins are before you sell
How to Sell Rare CoinsWhat makes a coin rare and how to sell it
How to Sell Inherited CoinsA guide for families and executors
Rare Coin Value GuideApproximate values for U.S. coins and paper money
Coin Grading and AuthenticityAuthenticity, grade, and valuable error coins
Morgan Silver Dollar Price GuidePrices and dates for Morgan silver dollarsSelling Coins to American Rarities: Quick Answers
How do I get a free coin appraisal?
Send us clear photos or an inventory list, and an experienced buyer will appraise your coins at no charge. Photograph the front and back of each coin in soft daylight without a flash, and for certified coins include the holder label. A partial list or a few group photos is fine for a large collection. Use the form on this page, text 720-600-4740 or email staff@americanrarities.com. Appraisals are usually done within 24 hours, and there is no obligation to sell.
What makes a coin valuable?
A coin’s value comes from five things: metal content, rarity, condition, demand and authenticity. U.S. dimes, quarters and half dollars dated 1964 and earlier are 90% silver, so they are always worth more than face value. Beyond metal, a low mintage, a key date or mint mark, a high grade with original surfaces, or a recognized error or variety can multiply a coin’s value. Age alone does not; many 100-year-old coins are common, while some modern coins are valuable.
Do I need to get my coins graded before selling them?
No, most coins sell best without being graded first. Professional grading by PCGS or NGC charges a fee per coin, plus shipping, and can take weeks, so it only makes sense for coins whose value rises enough with a certified grade. We give you a free grading opinion as part of every appraisal, and as an authorized PCGS, NGC and ANACS dealer we can submit the coins that would benefit. Learn more about selling PCGS, NGC and ANACS coins.
Should I clean my coins before I sell them?
No. Never clean, polish or dip a coin before selling it. Even gentle rubbing leaves fine hairline scratches and strips the original surface, and grading services label cleaned coins as “details” coins, which sell for much less than problem-free examples. Dark toning or dirt is normal on old coins and does not hurt value the way cleaning does. Keep coins in the holders, albums or Mint packaging they came in, and photograph them as they are. See why a coin cleaning mistake can destroy value.
Is it better to sell coins to a dealer, at auction or online?
It depends on what you have and how much time and risk you want to take on. Auctions can suit major rarities, but sellers usually pay a commission and wait weeks or months to be paid. Online marketplaces charge selling fees and leave you handling photos, shipping, returns and buyer disputes. Selling to an established dealer gives you a firm written offer and payment right away, with no fees. Compare what you will actually net after fees, not the advertised price. Our guide to coin shop vs. coin auction explains more.
How does the insured mail-in service work?
You get our written offer first, then ship your coins to us fully insured at our expense. Pack coins snugly in their holders inside a sturdy box so nothing shifts, and keep a copy of your inventory list and photos. We do not provide shipping materials, but we will tell you how to pack and send your package. Once your coins arrive, we pay you immediately by cash, check, ACH or wire. If you decline, we return your items fully insured. See how to safely ship a coin collection.
Why should I trust American Rarities?
We have bought coins since 1990 and have purchased over $400 million in coins, bullion and currency. Our buyers are Life Members of the American Numismatic Association, we are an authorized PCGS, NGC and ANACS dealer, and we hold an A+ BBB rating and a 4.7-star Google rating. Every offer is free, in writing and with no obligation, so you can compare it with others before deciding. Read what sellers say in our customer testimonials.
Free Appraisal for Your Coin and Paper Money Collections
Send Us Your Inventory List or Photos
Email: staff@americanrarities.com | Text Photos: 720-600-4740 | Or use the form below
Professional Associations
