Work With a Coin Dealer Who Understands Your Collection

American Rarities buyer Jim Noffsinger with a certified coin set, beside a collection-review worksheet

Searching for a coin dealer near you usually means you want more than a quick price. You want one knowledgeable person who looks at the whole collection, explains what they see and is still there when you have follow-up questions. That is the relationship this page is about.

American Rarities has been buying coins and collections since 1990, from Boulder, Colorado, and from sellers in every state. Most of our sellers have a mixed collection: some certified coins, some albums, a few gold pieces, foreign coins and paper money. We review it as one collection, not one coin at a time.

  • One accountable contact from the first photo to payment.
  • An explained offer that tells you what is included and why.
  • No pressure to sell everything, or anything, at once.
Decorative gold separator bar

Your First Conversation With a Coin Dealer

A good first conversation is about your goals, not our sales pitch. Expect to be asked:

  • What the collection includes. Coins, sets, albums, certified coins, bullion, paper money or foreign coins.
  • What records you have. Original receipts, inventory lists, grading labels or notes from the person who built the collection.
  • Whether you plan to sell all of it or part of it. Some sellers want to keep a few family pieces; that is fine.
  • How you would like to proceed. Photos first, insured mail-in at our expense, or a meeting for a larger collection.

You can start that conversation by texting photos to 720-600-4740, emailing staff@americanrarities.com or using the form below. All appraisal requests are reviewed in the order they are received. Some appraisals take minutes, while larger, more complex collections can take a few days. Either way, you’ll get a response from us.

Decorative gold separator bar

What an Explained Collection Offer Should Cover

Whoever you sell to, a collection offer should be something you can understand and check. Ours covers:

  1. Identification. What each coin or group is: type, date, mint mark and variety where it matters.
  2. Condition. Our grading opinion, and whether certification by PCGS, NGC or ANACS could make sense before a sale.
  3. Scope. Exactly which items the offer includes, so nothing is quietly left out.
  4. Items needing a closer look. Coins that need physical inspection before a final number, such as a possible rarity or a coin with questionable surfaces.

The appraisal is free. It is our liquid value appraisal and written offer, and you are under no obligation to sell. Want to see how other offers compare? Use our guide to compare written dealer offers.

Decorative gold separator bar

Working Together Over Several Conversations

Collections are rarely sold in one phone call. Many sellers ask questions over a few days or weeks, add items they find later or decide to sell in stages. That is normal, and you should never feel rushed.

Good questions to ask any dealer along the way:

  • Which coins drive most of the value, and why?
  • Are there coins you would not buy, and what should I do with them?
  • If I keep part of the collection, does the offer on the rest change?
  • How will I be paid, and when? (We pay immediately by cash, check, ACH or wire once you accept.)

Records to keep: your inventory list, the photos you sent, the written offer and your payment record. If you ship to us, keep your insured tracking number; if you decline, we return your items fully insured.

Decorative gold separator bar

Who You Are Working With

American Rarities has purchased over $400 million in coins and collections since 1990. We are ANA Life Members, hold an A+ BBB rating and a 4.7-star Google rating, and are an authorized PCGS, NGC and ANACS dealer. You can read more about our firm and credentials.

Not sure which service you need? Start with our guide to choosing the right buying or appraisal service. Have key dates or certified rarities? See selling key dates and certified rarities.

Decorative gold separator bar

Working With a Coin Dealer: Quick Answers

Do I have to sell my whole collection at once?

No. You can sell part of a collection and keep the rest, or sell in stages. We will tell you which coins carry most of the value so you can decide. Many sellers keep coins with family meaning and sell the rest, and an explained offer makes that choice easier.

Can I ask follow-up questions after I get an offer?

Yes. Ask as many questions as you need. A good dealer explains the offer, tells you what is included and why, and never pressures you to decide right away. You will have one accountable contact from the first photo to payment, so you are not passed from person to person.

I have a mix of coins, sets, paper money and bullion. Do you handle all of it?

Yes. We buy U.S. and world coins, U.S. paper money, and gold and silver bullion, so a mixed collection can be reviewed together and you get one offer for everything. Keep it together as you found it, along with any receipts, inventory lists or grading labels, since those records help us value it accurately.

Do you have a shop I can walk into?

No. We are based in Boulder, Colorado, and work by appointment, by photo and by insured mail-in at our expense, so there are no walk-in hours. For larger collections, one of our buyers can meet you at your home, office or bank. American Rarities has a presence in California, Colorado and Arizona, with buyers in several other states.

How do I start?

Text photos to 720-600-4740, email staff@americanrarities.com or use the form on this page. A rough list of what the collection includes is enough to begin. All appraisal requests are reviewed in the order they are received. Some appraisals take minutes, while larger, more complex collections can take a few days. Either way, you’ll get a response from us.

Decorative gold separator bar

Free Appraisal for Your Coins and Coin Collections

Email, Text, or Use This Form To Send Us Your Inventory List or Pictures

Email: staff@americanrarities.com Text: 720-600-4740 Or use the form below




Upload files of inventory lists and front and back photos of your items.

    We can help build your inventory list. Use the Collection List Maker to photograph your items and we'll build the inventory list for you.

    Decorative gold separator bar

    Collection-selling guides

    Best place to sell a collection

    Weigh shop, auction and private sale.

    Sell my rare coins

    Send photos for a free written offer.

    Mistakes to avoid when selling

    Common errors that cost sellers money.

    How to sell proof and mint sets

    Sets, packaging and what buyers check.

    Sell proof, mint and commemorative sets

    Cash offers on U.S. Mint products.

    Professional Associations

    American Rarities’ experts are American Numismatic Association (ANA) Life Members, and we hold an A+ rating with the Better Business Bureau.

    Professional association and grading-service logos including ANA Life Member, PMG, PCGS, NGC, ANACS, CAC, CCE and currency-grading organizations