Coin Selling Sites

The rare coin hobby and business has changed much in recent years. It’s harder and harder to find a local reputable coin dealer near you. Your precious collection and the money you invested into it is just gathering dust by the year. Thankfully, the internet has helped make it easier, with online coin selling sites becoming more popular. But not all sites are created equal

Always Paying More For Your Rare Coins

Best Way to Sell Coins

American Rarities has several distinct advantages to offer you.

For one, we’ll appraise your rare coin collection for free, and offer to buy all your coins at a mutually agreed upon price. This is different from other coin selling sites like ebay or, which have you take a chance by selling your coins in an auction for who knows what price. With those sites, you also lose money on the auction fees and other charges that are deducted from your payment. With us, there are no fees to worry about. Best of all, with us payment is immediate upon your acceptance of our hassle free no obligation offer.

Numismatic Experience you can count on for a Strong Offer.

In addition, we have a wealth of rare coin buying experience. Unlike most coin selling sites, we’ve been in business for over 30 years. Check out our Google Reviews. We are a member of the Better Business Bureau with an A+ rating. Our coin selling site first went up in 1994. That means we know the ins and outs of the rare coin hobby, and know how to make the process of parting with your precious coin collection as painless as possible.

Here’s how our coin buying process works:

  • You share your inventory list or pictures with us by email or text.
  • We’ll contact you via email (usually within 24 hours) with an initial appraisal value and offer.
  • If you decide to sell, we’ll either come to you, or you can use our fully insured Mail-In Service.
  • Upon our receipt our your coins, payment is immediately made via company check, ACH, or wire. It’s your choice.

It’s hard to find someone who understands how important it is to make sure you get a fair price for your coins. No other coin selling sites can match American Rarities for how much money we can save you and how easy we make the process.

Free Appraisal for Your Coins and Coin Collections

Email, Text, or Use This Form To Send Us Your Inventory List or Pictures

Professional Associations