How to Compare Local Coin Dealers Before You Sell

Two blank dealer-offer comparison worksheets beside one actual 1875-S trade dollar, for comparing fees and final net payment

If you already have a shortlist of local coin dealers, the hard part is comparing them fairly. Distance and a friendly counter are not enough. This page gives you the questions to ask, a worksheet to fill in and the red flags to watch for, so you can compare written offers on the same terms.

American Rarities has bought coins since 1990 and is happy to be one of the offers you compare. Send photos for a free liquid value appraisal (an offer to buy); appraisals are usually done within 24 hours, though larger collections may take longer. If so, we’ll let you know. There is no obligation to sell.

Decorative gold separator bar

Build a Shortlist That Fits Your Coins

  • Match expertise to the collection. A shop that mostly trades bullion may not be the best buyer for early U.S. coins, world coins or rare paper money.
  • Look for whole-collection buyers. If you have coins, sets, paper money and bullion, ask whether the dealer will make an offer on all of it.
  • Consider how they work. Some dealers have counters, some work by appointment, and some buy by photo review and insured mail-in.

Before you visit, read how to prepare for a shop visit. To check a dealer’s identity and reputation, see how to verify a dealer’s reputation.

Decorative gold separator bar

Interview Questions for Every Dealer

  1. What exactly does your offer include? Every coin, or only some?
  2. Who inspects the coins? Is the offer based on photos, or on a physical inspection?
  3. Are there any fees or charges? Ask about appraisal, shipping, insurance or other deductions.
  4. Will the offer be in writing? A written offer lets you compare like for like.
  5. How and when do you pay? Cash, check, ACH or wire, and how soon after you accept.

For reference, our free appraisal carries no fee or obligation, mail-in shipments are fully insured at our expense, and we pay immediately by cash, check, ACH or wire once you accept.

Decorative gold separator bar

Compare the Same Coins on the Same Assumptions

Offers are only comparable when they cover the same coins in the same condition. Give every dealer the same list and the same photos. Note any coin a dealer excluded, any coin it graded differently and any offer that is provisional until the coins are seen in person.

Offer comparison worksheet (print it or copy it into a notebook):

QuestionDealer ADealer BDealer C
Items included in the offer   
Items excluded, and why   
Is the offer final or provisional?   
Who inspected the coins?   
Any fees or charges?   
Payment method and timing   
Offer in writing?   
  • Obverse of an 1878-CC Morgan silver dollar from the Carson City Mint showing Liberty facing left with E PLURIBUS UNUM, on a transparent background
  • Obverse of a 1907 High Relief Saint-Gaudens $20 gold double eagle cut out on a transparent background
  • A Series 1901 $10 Legal Tender large-size note with an American bison at center between portraits of Lewis and Clark
  • 1884 Morgan silver dollar graded PCGS MS65 in a PCGS holder
  • 1925 Peace silver dollar graded ANACS MS64 in an ANACS holder
1875-S Trade dollar obverse, 1905 Barber half dollar reverse, 1851 large cent reverse, 1858 Flying Eagle cent and 1907 Indian Head cent, with every rim fully visible
Decorative gold separator bar

Red Flags in an Offer

  • Unexplained exclusions. Coins dropped from the offer without a reason.
  • Pressure. An offer that is only good if you decide right now.
  • Unclear written terms. No itemized list, no payment method or no date.
  • Vague answers about fees. Every charge should be stated up front.

Some dealers charge for appraisals and some do not. A professional appraisal for a purpose such as an estate or insurance is a different service from a liquid value appraisal (an offer to buy), and it may be priced separately. Just make sure you know which one you are being offered.

Decorative gold separator bar

A Second Offer to Compare

American Rarities has purchased over $400 million in coins, paper money and bullion since 1990. We are ANA Life Members with an A+ BBB rating and a 4.7-star Google rating. Some sellers want a continuing dealer relationship; others just want one more written offer. Either way, start with photos. If payment method is a deciding factor, compare payment methods.

Not sure which service you need? Use our guide to choose the right buying or appraisal service.

Decorative gold separator bar

Comparing Local Coin Dealers: Quick Answers

How many coin dealers should I compare?

Two or three written offers on the same list of coins is usually enough to see whether an offer is in line.

Why are offers from local coin dealers so different?

Dealers differ in grade opinions, which coins they include and where they can resell them. Comparing written offers on the same coins makes the differences clear.

Should I pay for an appraisal?

A liquid value appraisal (an offer to buy) is usually free. A professional appraisal for an estate or insurance is a separate service and may be priced differently. Ask which one you are getting.

Can American Rarities give me an offer to compare?

Yes. Text photos to 720-600-4740, email staff@americanrarities.com or use the form below. Appraisals are usually done within 24 hours, though larger collections may take longer. If so, we’ll let you know.

Decorative gold separator bar

Free Appraisal for Your Coins and Coin Collections

Email, Text, or Use This Form To Send Us Your Inventory List or Pictures



Upload clear photos of fronts and backs and we'll reply with a free appraisal.

    Decorative gold separator bar

    Compare offers with these guides

    How to sell gold coins

    Steps before you take a gold offer.

    Sell gold and silver bullion

    Bullion priced against the market.

    Sell U.S. paper currency

    Notes, nationals and type notes.

    Fake coin pictures

    Real counterfeits we have examined.

    Off-brand graded coins

    Selling coins in lesser-known holders.

    Professional Associations

    Professional association and grading-service logos including ANA Life Member, PMG, PCGS, NGC, ANACS, CAC, CCE and currency-grading organizations