Find Trusted Old Coin Buyers Near You

We have a wealth of experience and are ready to pay top dollar for your coins.

You’re here because you googled “old coin buyers near me, right? With the ongoing “retail apocalypse,” they’re not so easy to find in your local area. Besides having to drive with your collection in tow, coin shops are usually cash-strapped, or straight up biased toward making money at your expense, so you may not get an offer worthy of your hard earned, valuable coin collection.

Going online leads to new problems. First, you don’t have any idea who you’re dealing with, since a lot of buying takes place on auction sites like ebay and greatcollections . Also, the fees are enormous, ranging anywhere from 13% to 22%.

Thankfully, you found American Rarities. We’ve been in business since 1990 and have done over $400 million in numismatic transactions. We have a wealth of experience and are ready to pay top dollar for your coins.

We Buy Old Coins!

Hands exchanging rare U.S. gold coins for cash, illustrating the selling process with a trusted gold coin dealer.

How to Find a Reputable Buyer for Your Old Coins

First, you want to make sure the coin buyer is reputable by looking for a proven track record.

For example, when you googled “old coin buyers near me,” you found American Rarities; here are our credentials:

In other words, we have an objectively verifiable reputation for competence and fair dealing. We’re a reputable coin dealer, not some anonymous user on ebay.

After you find the buyer, it’s just a matter of following the selling process.

Our Stress-Free Selling Process

Various valuable old gold, silver, and copper coins being appraised through our stress-free selling process by expert old coin buyers.
Our stress-free process makes it easy to sell all your old coins, from common silver to rare gold.

Our selling process is easy and straightforward.

  1. First, you’ll provide us with photos or a description of your inventory. This can be done via text, email, or by using the form below to contact us.
  2. Shortly after that, one of our knowledgeable and friendly coin buyers local to your area will reach out with an initial, written appraisal (either by text or email). This appraisal is IRS-approved, carries no obligation to sell, and is totally free. 
  3. For special cases, our coin buyer can meet you where you are to provide a second, on-the-spot appraisal, as well as an offer to buy. 
  4. If you agree to the offer, we’ll pay you as soon as the items are checked in.

And then you’re done! Pretty simple, right? Reach out to us today to get started using the Contact Us Form below to get started!

Explore Our Expertise & Resources: Learn more about the value in your collection and our unique process with these helpful guides:

Contact us today to get started on your free appraisal!

Free Appraisal for Your Coins and Coin Collections

Email, Text, or Use This Form To Send Us Your Inventory List or Pictures

Email: staff@americanrarities.com | Phone: 800-622-5680 | Text: 720-600-4740

Professional Associations