Sell a Rare Coin for Its Full Value

Rare U.S. coins for sale appraisal: a 1907 Saint-Gaudens double eagle at center with a Peace dollar, Walking Liberty half, Mercury dime, Indian cent, Buffalo nickel and Indian Head $5 gold piece on a gold background

Found one coin that looks special? Maybe it is a gold piece from a grandparent, an old silver dollar with an unusual mint mark, or a single key date you bought years ago. You do not need a whole collection to sell a rare coin. You need an honest answer about what it is, what it is worth, and who will pay you fairly for it.

American Rarities has bought rare coins since 1990, with more than $400 million in purchases, an A+ rating from the Better Business Bureau and a 4.7-star average from 86 Google reviews. We buy one coin or many: rare U.S. coins, foreign coins, gold and silver bullion and paper currency.

Selling a larger group? See Sell My Rare Coins for whole and inherited collections, or Sell Collector Coins for type sets, commemoratives and albums.

Decorative gold separator bar

Is Your Coin Rare? 5 Things That Decide Its Value

A coin is not rare just because it is old. Plenty of 150-year-old coins are common, while some coins from the 1900s are scarce. These five things decide whether your coin is a rarity and what a buyer will pay:

  • Mintage: how many were struck. The U.S. Mint records production for every year and mint, and low-mintage dates such as the 1909-S VDB Lincoln cent or the 1916-D Mercury dime stand out.
  • Survival: how many are left. Many coins were melted, lost or worn down, so a coin with a large mintage can still be hard to find in nice condition.
  • Condition (grade): coins are graded on the 1 to 70 Sheldon scale, explained in the NGC grading scale. A small step up in grade can change the value of a rare date many times over.
  • Mint mark and variety: a tiny letter, a doubled die or a design change can turn an ordinary coin into a key. Our guide to error coins and die varieties shows what to look for.
  • Demand and eye appeal: famous designs such as the Saint-Gaudens double eagle attract strong collector demand, and original color and luster add value.

To research on your own, browse the NGC U.S. coin price guide, PCGS CoinFacts, or the Smithsonian’s National Numismatic Collection, or try our coin value finder. Not sure if your coin is genuine? Read about coin authentication.

Decorative gold separator bar

Why Sell Your Rare Coin to American Rarities

Hands in white shirt sleeves counting cash between gold and silver coins: find your coin’s value and get a written offer if you want to sell
  • A specialist looks at your coin: we check date, mint mark, variety, grade and eye appeal, using XRF metal testing and digital microscopy when needed, so a rare coin is not priced like a common one.
  • Graded or raw: as a PCGS and NGC authorized dealer and ANACS submission center, we buy PCGS, NGC and ANACS graded coins and give raw coins a free in-house grade, so you do not have to pay to slab a coin before you sell it.
  • No fees: no appraisal, listing, auction or insurance fees, and no obligation to accept our offer. We offer free or discounted shipping on selected collections, and mail-in shipments are fully insured with no deductible.
  • Fast offers, immediate payment: most offers go out All appraisal requests are reviewed in the order they are received. Some appraisals take minutes, while larger, more complex collections can take a few days. Either way, you’ll get a response from us. Once you accept we pay right away by check, wire or ACH.
  • In person if you prefer: for qualifying coins and collections, a buyer from our nationwide network can meet you at your home, office or bank. See why our rare coin buyers pay more.

A local shop may focus on bullion and miss a scarce variety, and selling online means photos, fees and weeks of waiting. With us, one rare coin gets the same expert attention as a large collection. American Rarities members are American Numismatic Association Life Members, and for estate or donation values we also provide IRS-compliant appraisals.

Decorative gold separator bar

How to Sell a Rare Coin in 5 Steps

Smartphone camera with a light screen photographing a 1795 Flowing Hair silver dollar, slightly over a handwritten list of rare U.S. coins

1Send Photos and/or a List

Photograph the front and back of your coin and send the photos with the form on this page, by text to 720-600-4740 or by email to staff@americanrarities.com. A short list works too. Include any grading service and certification number.

American Rarities written appraisal and offer sheet listing 1795 Flowing Hair and Draped Bust dollars, a 1917-S Standing Liberty quarter and 1855 half dimes, with an Eschenbach 5X loupe

2Free Appraisal and Written Offer

A rare coin specialist checks authenticity, grade and variety and sends you a free written offer with no obligation to sell. All appraisal requests are reviewed in the order they are received. Some appraisals take minutes, while larger, more complex collections can take a few days. Either way, you’ll get a response from us.

A taped, padlocked carton addressed to American Rarities and marked fully insured, turned at an angle, ready to ship a rare coin

3Ship Fully Insured, Paid by Us

Ship the coin in its holder, packed snugly in your own sturdy box, fully insured at our expense with no deductible. We do not provide shipping materials. If you decline, we return it fully insured.

Our buyer examines an 1855 Seated Liberty half dime with a loupe while a customer watches, with a 1795 Draped Bust dollar and a 1917-S Standing Liberty quarter on the table

4Or Meet a Buyer in Person

For important coins and collections, a buyer can meet you at your home or office, or we can meet you at your bank.

Four ways to get paid for a rare coin, stacked two by two: cash, check, ACH and wire

5Get Paid Immediately

Accept the offer and we pay you immediately by cash, check, ACH or wire.

Rare Coin Questions

How do I know if my coin is rare?

Rarity depends on how many were minted, how many survive, the condition, the mint mark and any variety. Age alone does not make a coin rare: many 150-year-old coins are common, while some 20th-century dates are scarce. Send clear photos of both sides and a specialist will tell you for free whether your coin is a rarity and what it is worth.

Can I sell just one rare coin?

Yes. We buy single rare coins as well as collections, raw or graded, and every coin gets a free, no-obligation offer. A single gold piece or key date gets the same specialist review as a large collection. If you accept, we pay immediately, and you can ship your coin fully insured or, for a valuable coin, arrange to meet us at your bank.

Should I get my rare coin graded before selling it?

Usually not. We give raw coins a free in-house grade and can tell you whether third-party grading by PCGS or NGC would add enough value to be worth the fees and the wait. Grading tends to pay off for genuine key dates, high-grade coins and coins whose value changes a lot from one grade to the next. As an authorized dealer, we can submit coins for you.

How much does a rare coin appraisal cost?

Our appraisal is free, with no obligation to sell. It is a liquid value appraisal, meaning a written offer of what we would pay for your coin today. A formal written appraisal for insurance, an estate or a donation is a different service, usually paid, and we also prepare IRS-approved written appraisals. Be cautious of anyone who charges a percentage of a coin’s value to appraise it.

How can I tell if my rare coin is fake?

Be most cautious with key dates and gold, the coins most often counterfeited or altered. Common tricks include added or removed mint marks, altered dates and cast copies with soft, grainy details. A coin’s weight and diameter should match its official specifications, but good fakes can pass those checks. We test coins with XRF metal analysis and digital microscopy, and certification by PCGS or NGC guarantees authenticity.

Decorative gold separator bar

Free Appraisal & Offer To Buy Your Rare Coins

Email, Text, or Use This Form To Send Us Your Inventory List or Pictures



Upload files of inventory lists and front and back photos of your items.

    We can help build your inventory list. Use the Collection List Maker to photograph your items and we'll build the inventory list for you.

    Decorative gold separator bar

    Professional Associations

    Professional association and grading-service logos including ANA Life Member, PMG, PCGS, NGC, ANACS, CAC, CCE and currency-grading organizations