Coin Dealer Near Me: How to Find a Trusted Coin Dealer in Your Area
If you searched for “coin dealer near me”, you are not alone. Many local coin shops have closed over the years, and the ones that remain may not have the expertise, or the budget, to make a strong offer on a valuable collection.
The good news is that you do not need a shop on your street corner. American Rarities has been buying rare coins since 1990, and we offer free appraisals by photo and home visits nationwide. We buy U.S. and world rare coins, U.S. paper money, and all gold and silver bullion, including bars. Over more than 30 years we have purchased over $350 million in coins and collections.
Are you a collector looking to buy or trade rather than sell? See our coin collector near me page.
Have something that needs an expert in one category, such as key dates, gold, world coins, paper money or errors? See our coin specialist near me page.
Why Is It So Hard to Find a Coin Dealer Near Me?
We get it. Everyone prefers to sell to a coin dealer in their own area, where they can meet face to face. That is why we built a nationwide network of coin buyers. For larger collections, one of our experts can come to your home or office, appraise your coins in person for free, and make you an offer on the spot.
Local options have limits, too. Pawn shops and “cash for gold” buyers usually price rare coins at melt value and ignore the numismatic premium that can make a coin worth far more than its metal. A local coin shop working on tight margins may not have the capital for a large collection, so it may cherry-pick the best few coins and leave you with the rest. We make an offer on the entire collection.
Prefer to ship? Mail-in shipments are fully covered with no deductible, so your coins are protected from your door to ours, and we offer free or discounted shipping on selected collections.
Selling certified coins? American Rarities is a PCGS authorized dealer, an NGC authorized dealer and an ANACS submission center. We submit coins to all three and deal in coins and paper money certified by them and by other grading services. See our NGC coin dealer near me and PCGS coin dealers near me pages.
Want to compare your options first? Our guide to local coin dealers explains how to find and evaluate a dealer, what to bring and how a local visit compares with mail-in and home visits. Looking specifically for someone to buy key dates, early U.S. coins or rare paper money? See our rare coin buyers near me.
Always Paying More For Your Rare Coins
How to Choose a Trustworthy Coin Dealer
Whether the dealer is down the street or across the country, look for these signs of a reputable business:
- Credentials. Membership in the American Numismatic Association and a strong Better Business Bureau rating.
- Real reviews. A long track record of verified customer reviews.
- Grading knowledge. The dealer should explain how your coins grade and whether certification by PCGS, NGC or ANACS makes sense.
- Authentication tools. Professional dealers can authenticate coins and test metal content.
- Clear payment. Written offers and prompt, traceable payment.
For more tips, read our guide on how to find the best rare coin dealer.
Here is how American Rarities measures up:
- Buying and selling rare coins since 1990, with over $350 million purchased
- A+ rating from the Better Business Bureau
- American Numismatic Association Life Members
- A 4.7 Google rating from 86 Google reviews
- PCGS and NGC authorized dealer and ANACS submission center; we submit coins to all three
- Free grading opinions (we do not encapsulate coins)
- XRF testing and digital microscopy
- IRS-compliant appraisals for estates, CPAs and fiduciaries
- Immediate payment by company check, wire or ACH
- Auction house partnerships with preferential auction fees for top rarities
How Do I Find Out What My Coins Are Worth?
Through an appraisal. American Rarities appraises and grades coins for free, with no obligation to sell. (Our grades are expert opinions; we do not encapsulate coins, but we can submit them to PCGS, NGC or ANACS for you when certification makes sense.) Here is how it works:
- Send us clear photos or a list of your coins by text to 720-600-4740, by email, or with the form below.
- We usually reply within 24 to 48 hours with a free appraisal and offer. If you need a formal, IRS-compliant appraisal for an estate, insurance or a donation, just ask.
- For larger collections, an expert can visit you at home anywhere in the country. Or mail your coins to us, fully covered with no deductible.
- Accept the offer and we pay immediately by company check, wire or ACH.
Want a rough idea of value first? Check our coin collector’s price guide. Learn more about our free online coin appraisal, coin collection appraisal, coin appraisers in your area, estate appraisals and coin collection buyers.
Coin Dealer Near Me FAQ
Do you have a coin shop I can visit?
We work mostly by appointment, by photo and by mail. For larger collections we offer home visits nationwide, so you do not have to travel.
What kinds of coins do you buy?
U.S. and world rare coins, certified and raw coins, U.S. paper money, and all gold and silver bullion, including bars.
Do I need to get my coins graded before I sell?
No. We grade coins for free (without encapsulation) and will tell you if PCGS, NGC or ANACS grading is worth the fee. If it is, we can submit your coins for you.
How fast will I get an offer and payment?
We usually reply to photo submissions within 24 to 48 hours, and we pay immediately by company check, wire or ACH once you accept.
Is it safe to take my coins to a local shop for an appraisal?
Carrying valuable coins to a storefront is a security risk. With American Rarities you can get a free appraisal from home by sending photos or a list, and for larger collections an expert can come to you.
Can I just use a coin value app instead of a dealer?
Apps are fine for general research, but they cannot judge eye appeal, luster or grade, and a single grade point can change a coin’s value dramatically. Only a professional appraiser can make a firm offer based on your coins’ actual condition.
Do you buy junk silver bags as well as rare coins?
Yes. We buy all gold and silver bullion, including junk silver bags and gold and silver bars, at current market prices.
I am a trustee or executor. What documentation do you provide?
We provide a written appraisal and a written offer, so the estate has a clear paper trail. If you need a formal, IRS-compliant appraisal, just ask. Selling to one national buyer also spares you the work of managing separate sales through several local outlets. See our estate appraisals page.
How do I contact you?
Text 720-600-4740, email us, or use the form below.
Looking for a specific area? See our pages for Los Angeles, Phoenix, Denver and New Jersey, or browse our California coin dealer page.
Free Appraisal for Your Coins and Coin Collections
Email, Text, or Use This Form To Send Us Your Inventory List or Pictures
Email: staff@americanrarities.com | Text: 720-600-4740 | Or use the form below
Professional Associations
American Rarities’ experts are American Numismatic Association (ANA) Life Members, and we hold an A+ rating with the Better Business Bureau.
