Private Coin Buyers

  • Post category:Articles

How Do I Sell My Coins for Cash?

When you start looking at options to sell your coin collection, ideally you would like to find private rare coin buyers who share your passion for coin collecting and understand the true value of your collection. But realistically it can be quite difficult to find private coin buyers like that. 

Oftentimes when you try to find private coin buyers you may find yourself drawn to auction sites such as or We strongly advise against this route, as not only do you have to pay auction fees out of your pocket, but there is no guarantee that you’ll get paid the full value of your hard earned, valuable collection.

Fortunately, American Rarities is different. We have the experience, connections, and trustworthiness you look for in private coin buyers.

Our Selling Process

Our process is made to reassure any doubts in working with us.

First, you’ll start off by providing us with photos and a description of your collection. 

One of our friendly, experienced coin buyers will get back to you with a written initial appraisal and offer. This appraisal is free, IRS-approved, and carries no obligation. For high-value collections, we can set up an in-person meeting with one of our local coin buyers from our nationwide network to physically appraise and purchase your collection.

If you accept, payment is made immediately the same day that we receive the coins. And don’t worry, if you ship your coins, we fully insure all shipments at our expense. 

The American Rarities Advantage

When it comes to finding private coin buyers, American Rarities is the best of both worlds: the comfortable feeling of a local transaction, combined with the resources of a larger coin dealer. Check to see where our coin buyers are near you!