Best Place to Sell Coins Online

Where’s the best place to sell coins online? Find a reliable coin dealer to sell to, whether online or in person.

Where’s the best place to sell coins online? That’s a crucial question in today’s evolving market. With local coin shops becoming increasingly scarce on Main Street and the unfortunate rise of online scams, it’s never been more challenging to find a reliable coin dealer to sell coins online to, or even in person. You need a trusted partner who combines the convenience of the internet with genuine expertise and fair dealings.

Well, you’re in luck. In just a few short moments, you’ll discover why American Rarities is widely recognized as the best place to sell rare coins online, providing a secure, transparent, and highly rewarding experience. We believe in always paying more for your rare coins, and our online process is designed to prove it.

Always Paying More For Your Rare Coins

new-hands-money-coins

Why American Rarities is the Best Place to Sell Coins Online

When considering where to sell your coin collection online, American Rarities stands out. Beyond our extensive numismatic experience, here are three compelling reasons why you’ll want to choose us:

1. Unmatched Experience in Online Coin Sales

One primary reason we are the best place to sell coins online is our profound experience in the numismatic market. We’ve been a trusted coin dealer for more than three decades, a testament to our longevity and expertise. In that time, we’ve purchased over $400 million worth of diverse numismatic material. Our experience spans:

  • All types of rare coins, from key dates to certified issues.
  • Common coins that complete larger collections.
  • Intriguing error coins and unique variety coins.
  • Valuable foreign coins and world currency.
  • All forms of gold, silver, platinum, and palladium bullion.

When you factor in the combined experience of our nationwide network of expert coin buyers and appraisers, we represent hundreds of years of collective knowledge in dealing with rare coins, paper money, and precious metals. This vast experience translates directly into accurate coin appraisals and competitive cash offers for your collection.

2. A Reputation You Can Trust When Selling Coins Online

Another major reason we’re the best place to sell coins online is our unwavering commitment to maintaining a strong reputation as an honest coin dealer. Our decades of experience have allowed us to build a reputation for excellence and integrity within the numismatic community. That reputation is clearly reflected in our:

  • A+ Rating from the Better Business Bureau (BBB), indicating superior customer service and ethical business practices.
  • Life Membership in the American Numismatic Association (ANA), a testament to our enduring commitment to the hobby and its standards.
  • Numerous Five-Star Google Reviews, where countless satisfied customers share their positive experiences of selling their valuable coins and bullion to us.

When it comes to numismatics, we don’t just say we know what we’re doing; our track record and third-party endorsements prove it. You can confidently sell your coin collection online to a company known for trustworthiness.

2. A Reputation You Can Trust When Selling Coins Online

Another major reason we’re the best place to sell coins online is our unwavering commitment to maintaining a strong reputation as an honest coin dealer. Our decades of experience have allowed us to build a reputation for excellence and integrity within the numismatic community. That reputation is clearly reflected in our:

  • A+ Rating from the Better Business Bureau (BBB), indicating superior customer service and ethical business practices.
  • Life Membership in the American Numismatic Association (ANA), a testament to our enduring commitment to the hobby and its standards.
  • Numerous Five-Star Google Reviews, where countless satisfied customers share their positive experiences of selling their valuable coins and bullion to us.

When it comes to numismatics, we don’t just say we know what we’re doing; our track record and third-party endorsements prove it. You can confidently sell your coin collection online to a company known for trustworthiness.

3. Superior Value and Flexibility for Your Online Coin Sale

Finally, a major reason we’re the best place to sell coins online is the exceptional value and flexibility we offer, designed to maximize your return:

  • Top Dollar Offers: Due to our national reach and philosophy of operating with razor-thin margins, we make a practice of paying top dollar for numismatic rare coins or gold and silver bullion material. Our business model allows us to consistently offer more competitive prices than many others in the market.
  • Comprehensive Purchase of Your Entire Collection: Unlike online auction sites or local dealers who might “cherry-pick” only the best items, leaving you with harder-to-sell common material, we are prepared to buy your entire coin collection for a mutually agreed-upon price. This saves you time, effort, and ensures you liquidate your whole collection efficiently.
  • Avoid Costly Fees: If you were considering the auction route for the sale of your coin collection, we’ll save you money on a variety of fees commonly associated with selling elsewhere:
    • No Auction Fees: Avoid commissions (13% to 22% of the sale on platforms like eBay or HA.com).
    • No Appraisal Fees: Our expert coin appraisal is always free, with no obligation to sell.
    • No Insurance Fees: Your collection is fully insured, at our expense, during transit.
    • No Shipping Fees: For collections valued over $400, we cover all shipping costs, providing a secure and convenient transport solution.

Best of Both Worlds – Online Convenience with a Personal Touch: We offer the convenience of an online submission and appraisal process, without the “cherry-picking” or lowball offers that can plague other online platforms. Meanwhile, thanks to our nationwide network of coin dealers covering every state, we’re able to make in-person appraisals and offers for larger or more valuable coin collections, giving you the benefit of a local expert where needed.

How Can I Sell My Coins Online? Our Simple Process:

Selling your coins online to American Rarities is designed to be straightforward and stress-free. Here’s how our secure process works:

  1. Initial Online Appraisal: You’ll start by providing us with an inventory list or clear photos of your collection. You can easily do this via text, email, or by uploading them directly through our secure Contact Us page. Our experts will then review this information to begin your free coin appraisal and formulate an accurate initial offer.
  2. Receive a Written Offer: We will promptly provide you with a competitively priced, written offer for your coins. This offer carries no obligation to sell and is transparent. For special cases involving very large or unique collections, we may arrange for one of our expert coin appraisers to meet you at your home or business for a physical appraisal.
  3. Secure Shipping (if applicable): If you accept our offer and decide to ship the coins to us, we’ll provide detailed instructions and fully insure your coins for free, so there’s nothing to worry about. You’ll receive active tracking and updates, ensuring complete peace of mind.
  4. Immediate Payment: Once your collection is received and verified, we’ll process payment immediately via a method of your choice. Options include company check, e-check, ACH (direct deposit), or wire transfer, ensuring you get cash for your coins without delay.
How Can I Sell My Coins Online? Provide us with an inventory list or pictures. We’ll reach back out to you with a free written appraisal.

Selling your coins online to American Rarities is designed to be straightforward and stress-free. Here’s how our secure process works:

  1. Initial Online Appraisal: You’ll start by providing us with an inventory list or clear photos of your collection. You can easily do this via text, email, or by uploading them directly through our secure Contact Us page. Our experts will then review this information to begin your free coin appraisal and formulate an accurate initial offer.
  2. Receive a Written Offer: We will promptly provide you with a competitively priced, written offer for your coins. This offer carries no obligation to sell and is transparent. For special cases involving very large or unique collections, we may arrange for one of our expert coin appraisers to meet you at your home or business for a physical appraisal.
  3. Secure Shipping (if applicable): If you accept our offer and decide to ship the coins to us, we’ll provide detailed instructions and fully insure your coins for free, so there’s nothing to worry about. You’ll receive active tracking and updates, ensuring complete peace of mind.
  4. Immediate Payment: Once your collection is received and verified, we’ll process payment immediately via a method of your choice. Options include company check, e-check, ACH (direct deposit), or wire transfer, ensuring you get cash for your coins without delay.
How Can I Sell My Coins Online? Provide us with an inventory list or pictures. We’ll reach back out to you with a free written appraisal.

Committed to Trust and Security

At American Rarities, we prioritize your security and privacy throughout the entire process of selling your coin collection online. Our reputation as a reliable coin dealer is built on trustworthiness and integrity.

  • Private and Confidential: All transactions and communications, whether online or in-person, are handled with the utmost discretion and confidentiality.
  • Fully Insured Shipping: Our mail-in service guarantees that your valuable collection is fully insured from the moment it leaves your hands until it reaches our secure facility. This coverage has no deductible, meaning you are fully protected.
  • Active Tracking & Updates: You receive active tracking information and automatic updates for your shipped packages, providing complete peace of mind.

What Customers Say About Selling to American Rarities:

"American Rarities truly is the best place to sell a coin collection.
I was looking for a trustworthy company to handle my father's inherited collection, which included some valuable rare coins, and their expert appraisal and transparent process exceeded all my expectations.
I received a fair offer and quick payment.
Highly recommend them for selling rare coins!"

Find Your Local Coin Buyer:
Our Nationwide Network

American Rarities serves collectors and sellers nationwide. While this page details why we are the best place to sell your coin collection generally, we also offer specialized service and expertise in your specific state. Find your local coin buyer and learn more about our services in your area:

Get a Free Appraisal for Your Coins and Coin Collections!

If you’ve gotten this far, you’re probably at least curious about seeing if we’re for real. As stated before, we offer free appraisals, so you have nothing to lose by trying us out! Once you do, we’re confident you’ll see why American Rarities is the best place to sell coins online!

Email, Text, or Use This Form To Send Us Your Inventory List or Pictures

Email: staff@americanrarities.com | Phone: 800-622-5680 | Text: 720-600-4740

Professional Associations

Footer-Logo-New-b