Customer Testimonials & Reviews

At American Rarities, trust is the foundation of our business. For over 30 years, we have been committed to providing a professional, fair, and respectful experience for every client. But you don’t have to take our word for it.

Below, you will find a collection of real letters and emails from satisfied sellers across the country. These testimonials speak to the integrity of our nationwide team and our dedication to making the process of selling a collection a positive one.

Morgan silver dollar beside a folding Zeiss 5X jeweler's loupe on a gold background, representing a knowledgeable rare coin appraisal
© American Rarities. Illustrative photorealistic header image created for American Rarities. Zeiss is a third-party brand name shown for illustration; the name is not owned by American Rarities.

“Very Knowledgeable”: A Review of American Rarities & Lee Block

Lee was very knowledgeable and was very interesting to talk to. Thanks, Ronald P. Brooks, MN American Rarities Reviews

Comments Off on “Very Knowledgeable”: A Review of American Rarities & Lee Block
Morgan dollar, Buffalo nickel, Walking Liberty half dollar and Mercury dime in slabs from off-brand grading services SEGS, ACCGS, NNC and INB on a gold background
© American Rarities. Illustrative photorealistic header image created for American Rarities.

A Collector’s Lesson: “Not All Grading Companies Are Created Equal”

Understanding coin grading can be one of the most confusing parts of selling a collection. As a seller from Belvidere, Illinois, recently learned, not all grading companies are created equal,…

Comments Off on A Collector’s Lesson: “Not All Grading Companies Are Created Equal”
Saint-Gaudens gold double eagles, Standing Liberty quarters and Indian Head cents beside a wooden box of coins, a leather ledger and a magnifying glass on a gold background
© American Rarities. Illustrative photorealistic header image created for American Rarities.

Customer Review: “Most Impressed with His Diligent Efforts”

For many families, selling a loved one's collection is a significant event. It's a process that requires not only numismatic expertise but also professionalism and respect. We were honored to…

Comments Off on Customer Review: “Most Impressed with His Diligent Efforts”
Small gold and silver bullion bars stacked on a gold background
© American Rarities. Illustrative photorealistic header image created for American Rarities.

Customer Review: “A PURE PLEASURE to Deal With”

  Dear Warren and Ryan:  From first moment to conclusion, it has been a PURE PLEASURE to deal with the fine gentlemen that you both PROVE to be ~ wishing only…

Comments Off on Customer Review: “A PURE PLEASURE to Deal With”
Liberty Head ten dollar gold eagles beside a blank price sheet and pencil on a gold background
© American Rarities. Illustrative photorealistic header image created for American Rarities.

Customer Review: A “Hard Working, Fair, and Very Knowledgeable” Numismatist

Our commitment to our clients in Florida is to provide a fair, honest, and educational appraisal, regardless of the collection's value. We understand the difference between retail and wholesale pricing…

Comments Off on Customer Review: A “Hard Working, Fair, and Very Knowledgeable” Numismatist
Blue coin album of Jefferson nickels with one empty hole and a loose nickel on a gold background
© American Rarities. Illustrative photorealistic header image created for American Rarities.

American Rarities Review: “The Result Was Excellent”

Our top priority is ensuring every client is happy with the final result of their sale. We work diligently to provide a professional experience and an excellent outcome. We appreciate…

Comments Off on American Rarities Review: “The Result Was Excellent”
A bundle of tied letters and a fountain pen beside Indian Head two and a half dollar gold quarter eagles on a gold background
© American Rarities. Illustrative photorealistic header image created for American Rarities.

American Rarities Review: A “No Pressure” Selling Experience

"A Smooth and Professional Transaction" - A Recent Seller's Review Selling a collection should be a positive and empowering experience, not a stressful one. We are committed to a "no-pressure"…

Comments Off on American Rarities Review: A “No Pressure” Selling Experience
A cream telephone handset beside Oregon Trail commemorative half dollars on a gold background
© American Rarities. Illustrative photorealistic header image created for American Rarities.

American Rarities Review: Earning a Seller’s Trust in Oregon

Trust isn't just a word; it's the foundation of every interaction we have with our clients. For sellers in Salem, Portland, and across Oregon, feeling that sincerity and respect from…

Comments Off on American Rarities Review: Earning a Seller’s Trust in Oregon
Cloth-bound books beside Braided Hair large cents on a gold background
© American Rarities. Illustrative photorealistic header image created for American Rarities.

American Rarities Review: A Patient & Educational Experience

We believe that a transparent and educational experience is just as important as a fair price. Our experts are committed to answering every question and ensuring you fully understand the…

Comments Off on American Rarities Review: A Patient & Educational Experience
Five Lincoln wheat cents below a green leather checkbook cover on a gold background
© American Rarities. Illustrative photorealistic header image created for American Rarities.

American Rarities Review: Earning a Collector’s Respect in MA

For a lifelong numismatist, selling a collection is about more than just money—it's about finding a buyer who shares the same respect for the coins. Our experts in Massachusetts understand…

Comments Off on American Rarities Review: Earning a Collector’s Respect in MA
Draped Bust silver dollars on a navy tray beside a folded blank check on a wooden table by a desert window
© American Rarities. Illustrative photorealistic header image created for American Rarities.

American Rarities Review: A Fair & Efficient Home Visit

For many clients, the thought of selling a collection can seem complicated and time-consuming. At American Rarities, we pride ourselves on making the entire process seamless, professional, and convenient. Our…

Comments Off on American Rarities Review: A Fair & Efficient Home Visit
Mexican 50 pesos gold coins, British gold sovereigns, Canadian silver Maple Leafs and a small platinum bar on a gold background
© American Rarities. Illustrative photorealistic header image created for American Rarities.

Customer Review: Going the Extra Mile for a Fair Market Value

Our promise is to provide the best possible price for every single item in your collection. For our clients in Georgia, this means our numismatic experts, like David Weinstein, will…

Comments Off on Customer Review: Going the Extra Mile for a Fair Market Value