Coin Appraisals for CPAs, Estates, Executors and Trustees

American Rarities appraiser sorting an estate coin collection in labeled trays, with a stereo microscope and an estate appraisal report on a clipboard
American Rarities appraiser sorting inherited coins and paper money into labeled trays, with an estate appraisal report on a clipboard

How Our Appraisals Support IRS Documentation

The IRS doesn’t require a specific license to appraise coins. What it looks for is a qualified appraiser with documented expertise. American Rarities appraises, buys and sells coins every day and has a long track record of work for estates, executors and trustees. Our reviews are the evidence: see our 4.7-star Google rating.

Form 706

Estate tax return. The main one. We document the date-of-death fair market value of each coin and note, with well-documented records so the values can hold up under IRS review.

Form 1041

Estate and trust income tax. Values for coins held by an estate or trust, and the basis to use when they are sold or distributed.

Form 709

Gift tax. Fair market value of gifted coins on the date of the gift.

Form 1120

Corporations. Documented value for coins and bullion held as corporate assets.

Form 1040

Individual income tax. Stepped-up basis, so heirs can figure gain or loss when inherited coins are sold.

Decorative gold separator bar

Free Coin Appraisals for Estates. All appraisal requests are reviewed in the order they are received. Some appraisals take minutes, while larger, more complex collections can take a few days. Either way, you’ll get a response from us.

American Rarities appraises coins, paper money and bullion for CPAs, executors, trustees, attorneys and other fiduciaries. Send us an inventory list or photos for a free, no-obligation appraisal. All appraisal requests are reviewed in the order they are received. Some appraisals take minutes, while larger, more complex collections can take a few days. Either way, you’ll get a response from us. When the estate file needs a formal, itemized date-of-death report, we prepare one as a separate, fee-based engagement.

Decorative gold separator bar

What We Do for Estates and Fiduciaries

A 1921 Peace silver dollar, a 1908 $5 Indian Head gold half eagle and an 1892 Barber dime, stacked at true relative sizeA 1921 Peace silver dollar, a 1908 $5 Indian Head gold half eagle and an 1892 Barber dime side by side at true relative size
  • Formal, itemized reports. Each coin or note is listed with photos, its grade and certification number, the valuation method and the comparable sales used.
  • Valuation dates. We value as of the date of death, or as of any other date you need, such as an alternate valuation date or a date of distribution.
  • Bullion and rare coins sorted. Bullion is valued by metal content; collectible coins by grade, rarity and comparable sales. We separate the two so the method is clear.
  • Paper money too. We appraise U.S. currency, such as large-size notes and national bank notes, along with the coins in the same report.
  • Ship insured or meet in person. Ship fully insured, or meet us in person for larger estates anywhere in the country.
  • If the estate decides to sell. We make an offer on the collection, and if it is accepted, we pay you immediately by cash, check, ACH or wire.

We provide coin and currency valuations, not tax or legal advice. The estate’s CPA or attorney decides how the values are reported.

Decorative gold separator bar

Guides for CPAs, Executors and Fiduciaries

Start with the guide that fits your role. Each covers one question in depth, and we add new guides here as they are published.

For CPAs and Tax Professionals

Coin Appraisal for Estate Tax: An IRS Documentation ChecklistWhat Form 706, Schedule F and Form 8971 call for, and the records that hold up on examination.

Step-Up in Basis and Date-of-Death ValuesHow inherited coins get their basis, and how fair market value is set on the date of death.

IRS-Compliant Numismatic Appraisals for CPAsWhat an itemized appraisal report from American Rarities includes.

Donating Coins to Charity: Form 8283When Form 8283 Section B and a qualified appraisal are required, and the related-use rule for coins.

Gifting Coins: Form 709 and Carryover BasisThe 2026 annual exclusion, when a gift tax return is due and the basis the recipient takes.

Gold IRA Coins: IRS RulesWhich coins an IRA can hold under section 408(m), trustee custody and liquidating IRA metals.

For Executors and Families

How to Sell Inherited CoinsA step-by-step guide for families and executors, from inventory to sale.

What to Do With Old Coins Found in an EstateHow to sort, handle and list coins before anyone cleans or sells them.

Tax Implications of Liquidating Bullion vs. Rare CoinsWhy bullion and rare coins are valued and taxed differently when an estate sells. Collectibles gain is taxed at a maximum 28% rate.

Coins Found While Downsizing: What to Do FirstA first-steps guide for professional organizers and downsizing experts.

Probate Inventory of CoinsHow an executor secures, inventories and values coins as of the date of death.

Dividing a Coin Collection Among HeirsEqual-value lots, rotation picks, buyouts and whether to sell or keep.

For Attorneys, Trust Officers and Advisors

Estate Appraisals and LiquidationOur full estate service, from the first inventory to the sale of the collection.

Red Flags in a Tangible Asset AppraisalA fiduciary’s audit checklist for reviewing any coin or collectibles appraisal.

For the Probate and Estate LawyerHow we work with attorneys handling an estate that includes coins.

For the Bank Trust OfficerHow we support trust departments with appraisals and liquidation.

Dividing a Coin Collection in DivorceMarital and separate coins, the valuation date and a neutral appraisal for both sides.

Coin Insurance AppraisalsReplacement value vs fair market value, scheduling coins on a policy and the records to keep.

Decorative gold separator bar

Why CPAs and Fiduciaries Work With American Rarities

  • Experience. Between all the buyers at and associated with American Rarities, we have hundreds of years of combined experience with U.S. coins, gold, silver and paper money.
  • Volume. Founded in 1990, we have purchased over $400 million in rare coins, paper money and precious metals.
  • Coordination. We work with the executor and keep you copied, so item numbers match your schedules and inventories.

To get started, send your inventory list or photos with the free appraisal form below.

Decorative gold separator bar

Get a Free Estate Coin Appraisal

Email, Text, or Use This Form To Send Us Your Inventory List or Pictures




Upload files of inventory lists and front and back photos of your items.

    We can help build your inventory list. Use the Collection List Maker to photograph your items and we'll build the inventory list for you.

    Decorative gold separator bar

    Your Next Step

    Rare Coin Value Guide

    Approximate values for U.S. coins and paper money, with melt values, in one place.

    How to Sell Guides

    Step-by-step guides to selling coins, whole collections and inherited coins.

    Free Appraisal Form

    Send photos or a list for a free, no-obligation appraisal and written offer. All appraisal requests are reviewed in the order they are received. Some appraisals take minutes, while larger, more complex collections can take a few days. Either way, you'll get a response from us.

    Why Clients Trust American Rarities

    4.7-Star Google Rating

    Read our Google reviews.

    A+ BBB Rating

    See our Better Business Bureau profile.

    ANA Life Members

    Our American Numismatic Association dealer listing.

    Authorized PCGS Dealer

    Professional Coin Grading Service.

    Authorized NGC Dealer

    Numismatic Guaranty Company.

    Authorized ANACS Dealer

    ANACS coin grading and authentication.