Get a Complimentary Online Coin Appraisal
Find out what your coins are worth from buyers who are ready to make you an offer. Send us photos or an inventory list, whether it’s one coin or a whole collection, and we’ll appraise everything at no charge. All appraisal requests are reviewed in the order they are received. Some appraisals take minutes, while larger, more complex collections can take a few days. Either way, you’ll get a response from us.
If you decide to sell, we pay immediately by cash, check, ACH or wire. If you just want to know what you have, that’s fine too.
- Over $400 Million Purchased
- 4.7-Star Google Rating
- Hundreds of Years of Combined Experience
- Member Dealers of PCGS and NGC
- Buying Nationwide
Prefer the phone? Leave a message at 800-622-5680 and we’ll call you back.
Start Your Complimentary Coin Appraisal
Email, Text, or Use This Form To Send Us Your Inventory List or Pictures
Email: staff@americanrarities.com Text: 720-600-4740
One Coin or a Whole Collection
Whether it’s a single coin you’ve always wondered about or boxes of coins from a lifetime of collecting, send it our way. We appraise every kind of U.S. coin, from copper cents and nickels to silver dollars and gold, plus the paper money and bullion that often turn up alongside them.

Just One Coin?
Send clear photos of the front and back. We’ll tell you what it is, what it’s worth and whether it’s worth getting graded.
A Whole Collection?
Start with an inventory list and/or some group photos. You don’t need a picture of every coin. A sampling is a fine place to start.
Paper Money or Bullion Too?
Include it. We also appraise U.S. paper money and gold and silver bullion, so you can send everything at once.
How Our Complimentary Coin Appraisal Works


1Send Photos and/or a List
The first step to get our complimentary appraisal and offer service started is easy: just send us at least a sampling of your collection in the way of an inventory list and/or pictures. Of course, the more information, the better. We’ll appraise everything and let you know what the values are.
Use the form on this page, text 720-600-4740 or email staff@americanrarities.com.


2Free Appraisal and Written Offer
Our numismatists review what you send. All appraisal requests are reviewed in the order they are received. Some appraisals take minutes, while larger, more complex collections can take a few days. Either way, you’ll get a response from us. You also get free in-house grading opinions, and when a coin would benefit from certification, we can help you submit it to PCGS or NGC. If you’d like to sell, we’ll put our offer in writing.


3Ship Fully Insured or Meet in Person
Ship your coins fully insured at our expense, with no deductible (we do not provide shipping materials). For larger collections, a buyer from our nationwide network can meet you at your home or office, or we can meet you at your bank. If you decline our offer, we return your coins fully insured.


4Get Paid (Cash, Check, ACH or Wire)
If you accept our offer, we pay immediately by cash, check, ACH or wire. We buy coins nationwide, and you’re never obligated to sell.
Photo Tips for a Faster, More Accurate Appraisal
- Photograph both sides of each coin, straight on, so the coin fills most of the frame.
- Use soft daylight from a window and turn off the flash to avoid glare.
- Tap the screen to focus so the date and mint mark are sharp.
- For certified coins, include the whole holder label and certification number.
- For rolls, sets or large groups, a few overview photos plus close-ups of the best coins is plenty.
- Never clean coins before photographing them. Cleaning can permanently reduce their value.
Why Sellers Choose American Rarities
- Experience. Between all the buyers at and associated with American Rarities, we have hundreds of years of combined experience with U.S. coins, gold, silver and paper money.
- Over $400 million purchased. We have bought over $400 million in coins, paper money and precious metals.
- Grading help. We’re member dealers of both PCGS and NGC. We give free in-house grading opinions and help you submit coins to PCGS and NGC when it makes sense.
- Paid immediately. Accept our offer and we pay immediately by cash, check, ACH or wire.
- 4.7-star Google rating. See what sellers say on Google.
- Nationwide. We buy coins and collections from sellers all across the country.
Free Online Coin Appraisal: Quick Answers
Is an online coin appraisal really free?
Yes. Our online coin appraisal is free and comes with no obligation to sell. It is free because we are buyers: we appraise your coins so we can make you an offer, and you are welcome to keep them if you choose. A formal written appraisal for insurance, estate or tax purposes is a different service, usually prepared by an appraiser for a fee. Send photos or a list with the form on this page, by text to 720-600-4740 or by email to staff@americanrarities.com.
How accurate is a coin appraisal from photos?
A photo appraisal is accurate enough to identify your coins, their dates, mint marks and approximate grade, and to tell you which ones are valuable. Sharp, glare-free photos of both sides make the biggest difference. Subtle problems such as light cleaning, small rim dings or very slight wear can be hard to see in a picture, so a coin’s exact grade, and its value if it is a high-grade rarity, is confirmed with the coin in hand or by PCGS or NGC certification.
How can I find out what my coin is worth for free?
Start by identifying the coin’s type, date and mint mark, then compare it with recent sales of the same coin in the same grade. Price guides from the grading services list retail values, and sold listings and auction records show what coins actually brought; asking prices on unsold listings are often far too high. Remember that a dealer’s buy price will be below retail. The quickest route is to send photos to an expert: we will tell you what you have and what it is worth, free.
Can I get my coins graded for free?
You can get a free grading opinion, but official certification always costs money. PCGS, NGC and ANACS charge a fee for each coin, plus shipping and handling, and turnaround can take weeks depending on the service level. Our numismatists give you a free in-house grading opinion with every appraisal and tell you which coins, if any, are worth certifying. As member dealers of PCGS and NGC, we can submit those coins for you, so you only pay grading fees where they make sense.
What is the difference between an appraisal value and an offer?
An appraisal value estimates what a coin is worth, while an offer is the amount a buyer will actually pay you today. Retail and insurance replacement values are higher than what any dealer pays, because dealers have costs and must resell at a profit. That is why a price guide number is not a cash price. Our appraisal tells you what your coins are worth, and our written offer tells you exactly what we will pay, so you can compare it with other offers.
Are coin identifier and value apps accurate?
Coin apps are useful for a quick identification, but their values are often unreliable. Image recognition can misread worn dates and mint marks, cannot judge grade or spot cleaning well, and often lists retail or asking prices instead of what coins actually sell for. Apps also flag ordinary damage as valuable errors. Use an app as a starting point, then have an expert check anything that looks promising. A free appraisal from an experienced buyer tells you both what the coin is and what it will bring.
Helpful Guides
Sell Rare U.S. CoinsHow we buy rare U.S. coins, from early copper to gold.
Coin Collection AppraisalWhat we look at when we appraise a large or mixed collection.
How to Sell Coins OnlineA step-by-step guide, from photos to payment.
Sell Paper MoneyLarge-size notes, silver certificates and other U.S. currency.
Gold and Silver BullionSelling bullion coins, bars and rounds.
Ready to find out what your coins are worth?
