Online Coins Buyer

Mixed US and world coins

Where Can I Sell My Old Coins Online for Cash?

Finding a reputable online coins buyer isn’t a simple decision. Many buyers are just looking for a quick payday, “cherry picking” the rarest coins out of people’s collections and lowballing them. Not to mention, a lot of these buyers are also anonymous  – do you really want to deal with that?

Thankfully, you found American Rarities – the best way to sell coins online!

Always Paying More For Your Rare Coins

Why We’re the Best Way to Sell Coins Online

We’re one of the biggest online coins buyers around, having done over $400 million in numismatics transactions since 1990. Unlike faceless buyers lurking auction sites for a quick payday at your expense, we got to where we are by offering the most competitive prices of any other online coins buyer.

We can offer such strong prices due to our nationwide network of numismatic experts and loyal following of coin collectors. We have online coin buyers available across the country, ready to evaluate your collection. And they won’t “cherry pick” or low ball you; they’ll buy your entire collection outright, at a fair and mutually-agreed upon price.

How Can I Sell My Old Coins?

Whether or not you’re ready to sell, get an appraisal from us first. American Rarities offers appraisals as a free service, with no obligation to sell. This is a great opportunity to find out what your coin collection is worth!

To get an appraisal, simply provide us with photos and an inventory description of your collection via text, email, or the Contact Us page.

One of our numismatic experts will then get back to you with an initial appraisal and offer to purchase. For special cases, they’ll even meet with you in-person for a physical appraisal and offer to buy on the spot.

If you decide to ship to us, we’ll insure your coins for free, and in many cases, we will pay for your postage. Once received, we’ll make sure money is in your hands ASAP

We Look Forward to Hearing From You!

If you’re searching for an online coins buyer for your precious collection, we don’t take that lightly. That’s exactly why you should lean on our A+ BBB-rated business and decades of experience to reliably and professionally assess your coin collection’s value.

Don’t settle for just any online coins buyer: deal with the best, American Rarities.

Free Appraisal for Your Coins and Coin Collections

Email, Text, or Use This Form To Send Us Your Inventory List or Pictures

Professional Associations