Private Coin Buyers

Mixed US and world coins

Looking for private coin buyers? You’ve come to the right place. American Rarities Numismatic Company is the premier buyer of any rare coins you may have.

From U.S. rare coins to foreign coins to mint error and variety coins, we’re interested in anything you have to offer.

The Problems with Finding Antique Coin Buyers

Sure, you could look for antique coin buyers in your area, but do you really want to spend your Saturday afternoons driving around with your valuable coin collection across town? Aside from the inconvenience involved, you could get there, just to find the owner isn’t fully knowledgeable about your particular coins and their true value. You also need to consider current economic conditions, which might incentivize cash-strapped coin shops to try to lowball you.

On the other hand, you could look online for private coin buyers. But that brings issues of its own. First, you gotta deal with outrageously high auction fees on sites like ebay and Stack Bowers, which may range anywhere from 13% to 22%. On top of that, you’re dealing with people trying to “cherry pick” your collection of all the good pieces, not to mention they’re anonymous, who knows what could happen?

Always Paying More For Your Coins

Why We’re Different

American Rarities brings the best of both the online and local numismatic experience. We’ve been in the numismatics business for over 30 years, and have conducted over $400 million in transactions. We’re also life members of the American Numismatic Association and have an A+ rating from the Better Business Bureau. So we’re a known quantity, not a random person on the internet; with us, you’re in good hands.

And, bringing a touch of the local, we have a nationwide network of private coin buyers near you, ready to meet with you to pay top dollar for your rare coin collection. Best of all, unlike other online private coin buyers, they won’t cherry pick; they’ll buy your entire collection at a mutually agreed-upon, fair price. This is both more economical and less aggravating for you.

Our antique coin buyers can even go to your business, bank, or home to buy from you in-person, if your collection warrants it. Private coin buyers off auction sites certainly aren’t going to do this!

Stress-Free Selling Process

Getting started with us is simple:

  1. First, you’ll provide us with photos or an inventory description of your collection. This can be done via text, email, or by using the Contact Us form.
  2. Shortly after that, one of our knowledgeable and friendly private coin buyers local to your area will reach out with a written, IRS-approved initial appraisal. This appraisal is totally free and carries no obligation to sell. If you need the collection graded first, we can do that as well (also for free).
  3. For special cases, our buyer can meet with  you to provide a physical, on-the-spot appraisal, with immediate payment.

Once you deal with us, you’ll see why we’re one of the best antique coin buyers anywhere. We look forward to hearing from you soon!

Free Appraisal for Your Coins and Coin Collections

Email, Text, or Use This Form To Send Us Your Inventory List or Pictures

Professional Associations