Reputable Coin Dealers

Mixed US and world coins

Reputable coin dealers aren’t always easy to find these days. Coin shops are increasingly a thing of the past. Those that are left are few and far between, with owners under heavy economic pressure to make money, and that may not always be the most educated when it comes to all aspects of numismatics.

If you’re looking for reputable coin dealers, you’ve come to the right place. American Rarities has over 3 decades of experience in the purchase and sale of numismatic coins, paper currency, and bullion. Since 1990, we’ve done over $400 million in business, paying top dollar for everything from U.S. rare coins, foreign coins, to mint error and variety coins. We also buy paper currency and every sort of bullion material. Our A+ BBB rating and American Numismatic Association member (#6360) attest to our impeccable reputation.

Always Paying More For Your Rare Coins

Why We The Most Honest and Reputable Coin Dealer Around

Here are some other benefits to working with us:

When you sell to us, we make the process simple and smooth. Simply text, email, or contact us using the form below to provide us details on your coin collection. All we need is an inventory list or some photos.

After that, one of our rare coin buyers will reach out via phone, or email, with an initial appraisal. For better collections, we may send our reputable coin dealer to meet you at your home, office, or bank, for a physical appraisal with an on the spot offer and payment. All appraisals come free of charge and with no obligation to sell.

After the appraisal, the buyer will then make an offer for a mutually agreed-upon price. If you accept, we make the sale as stress-free as possible. If you decide to ship, not only do we insure the shipment free-of-charge, we make sure payment is made upon items check in.

After doing business with us, you’ll see why “reputable coin dealers” and American Rarities Numismatic Company go hand-in-hand!

Free Appraisal for Your Coins and Coin Collections

Email, Text, or Use This Form To Send Us Your Inventory List or Pictures

Professional Associations