How to Get a Professional Appraisal for Your Coin Collection

Montage of U.S. and world gold and silver coins, including a Saint-Gaudens double eagle, Buffalo gold, Morgan and Seated Liberty dollars, a Kennedy half, a Krugerrand and a Canadian Maple Leaf

A coin collection appraisal tells you what your coins are really worth before you decide whether to sell, insure, divide an estate or simply keep collecting. At American Rarities we have appraised coin collections since 1990, more than 30 years, and have purchased over $400 million in rare coins, currency and bullion. Our appraisals are free, and there is never any obligation to sell.

Below is how a professional appraisal works, what we look at, and three simple tips that help your coin collection appraisal go quickly and smoothly. If you would rather start from your phone, our free online coin appraisal lets you send photos or a list in a few minutes.

What a Coin Collection Appraisal Covers

Saint-Gaudens double eagle, Seated Liberty dollar, Liberty double eagle reverse, Peace dollar, Indian Head eagle, Buffalo nickel and Indian Head cent on a gold background

Every coin is identified by type, date and mint mark, checked for authenticity and graded for condition. We then price it against current dealer and auction results, so you see what each piece and the whole collection is worth in today’s market. Where it matters, we confirm metal content with XRF testing and study surfaces and details under digital microscopy.

We appraise U.S. coins, world rare coins and paper money, and all gold and silver bullion, including bars. All appraisal requests are reviewed in the order they are received. Some appraisals take minutes, while larger, more complex collections can take a few days. Either way, you’ll get a response from us. For a deeper look at what drives a price, see our guide to how to determine the value of your rare coins.

For quick reference values, see our coin collector’s price guide. Prefer an appraiser who comes to you or works from photos? See our rare coin appraisal near me options.

Decorative gold separator bar

Three Tips for Getting Your Rare Coins Ready for Appraisal

Open U.S. type coin album with loose coins, protective holders and a coin tube, cleanly cut out for a coin collection appraisal

Here are three tips to prepare for your coin collection appraisal:

1. Sort Your Coins

Before you send photos or bring your coins to an appraiser, sort them by type, date, mint mark and condition. Keep coins in their original albums, flips, rolls or holders, and never clean them; cleaning can cut a coin’s value sharply.

It also helps to set aside coins with noticeably better or worse eye appeal, along with any that have holes, scratches or other damage. A simple inventory list, even a rough one, makes the appraisal faster and more accurate.

Morgan silver dollars certified by PCGS, NGC and ANACS side by side on a gold background under the heading PCGS vs. NGC vs. ANACS

2. Check Authenticity and Grade

Before you rely on any value, make sure your coins are genuine. Fake, counterfeit and altered coins can be hard to spot, especially gold and key-date silver.

We will check your coins’ authenticity and grade free of charge, help you separate fakes from genuine pieces. Coins already certified by PCGS, NGC, ANACS or CAC are valued from their grades. We grade your coins for free ourselves (we do not encapsulate them), and when certification will add value we can submit your coins to PCGS, NGC or ANACS for grading. As a PCGS and NGC authorized dealer and ANACS submission center, we will tell you which raw coins are worth certifying and which are not.

Coin expert at his desk examining a coin up close through a jeweler's loupe, with official PCGS and NGC slab storage boxes on the desk and a complete U.S. coin types poster on the filing cabinet

3. Choose a Reputable Coin Dealer

With your coins sorted and checked, the next step is choosing who will appraise them. Look for a dealer with a long track record, an established reputation and real buying power, because an appraisal is only as good as the offer behind it. Our guide on how to find the best rare coin dealer covers what to check.

Not sure where to start? Our coin dealer near me guide has a checklist for choosing a trustworthy dealer.

For more on what makes a stronger offer, read why our rare coin buyers pay more.

American Rarities has been in numismatics since 1990. We also:

  • Hold an A+ rating from the Better Business Bureau
  • Are Life Members of the American Numismatic Association
  • Are a PCGS and NGC authorized dealer and ANACS submission center
  • Have a 4.7-star Google rating from 86 reviews
  • Have purchased over $400 million in rare coins, currency and bullion
Decorative gold separator bar

Get a Free Coin Collection Appraisal Today

Camera-phone screen showing an 1899 Black Eagle silver certificate, a 1921 Peace dollar and an 1883 Liberty Head nickel for a coin collection appraisal

American Rarities offers coin collection appraisals as a free service, with no obligation to sell. Use us as a resource. When you need a formal valuation for an estate, a charitable donation or a CPA, we also provide IRS-compliant appraisals and estate appraisals and liquidation.

Getting started is easy. Send photos or an inventory list of your collection by email, by text to 720-600-4740, or with the form below, and we will reply promptly with our appraisal and an offer to buy. You can also:

  • Ship your coins using our mail-in service, fully covered with no deductible
  • Schedule a home visit; we travel nationwide for larger collections
  • Ask about consigning top pieces through our auction house partnerships at preferential auction fees

If you sell, payment is made immediately by company check, wire or ACH.

In New Jersey? See our page on coin dealers in New Jersey.

Related guides: sell old coins for cash, selling to an online coin buyer, how to sell a large coin collection and coin appraisal near me.

Decorative gold separator bar

Coin Collection Appraisal: Quick Answers

What does a coin collection appraisal include?

A coin collection appraisal identifies each coin by type, date and mint mark, checks it for authenticity, grades its condition and prices it against current dealer and auction results. Where it matters, we confirm metal content with XRF testing and examine surfaces under digital microscopy, which helps spot cleaning, alterations and counterfeits. You receive values for individual key pieces and the collection as a whole, so you can decide whether to sell, insure or divide it.

How much does a coin appraisal cost?

Our appraisal is free when you are considering selling, and there is no obligation. Formal written appraisals for insurance, estate settlement or charitable donations are sometimes prepared for a fee, typically hourly or a flat rate. Be wary of any appraiser who charges a percentage of the appraised value, since that rewards inflating the number and is considered unethical under appraisal standards. Ask what the appraisal is for before you hire anyone.

Where can I get my coin collection appraised?

You can have coins appraised by an established coin dealer, an auction house or an independent appraiser, and the right choice depends on why you need the appraisal. Dealers who buy coins can appraise and make an offer at the same time. Auction houses estimate what coins might bring at auction, before their fees. Independent appraisers prepare formal reports for insurance or legal purposes. Look for long experience, ANA membership and authorized dealer status with PCGS or NGC.

What is the difference between an appraisal for selling, insurance or an estate?

Each purpose uses a different value. An appraisal for selling tells you what the coins will actually bring. An insurance appraisal uses retail replacement value, which is higher. Estate and tax appraisals use fair market value as of a specific date, such as the date of death, and donations over $5,000 require a qualified appraisal for IRS Form 8283. We provide IRS-approved written appraisals for estates as well as free appraisals for selling.

How long does a coin appraisal take?

All appraisal requests are reviewed in the order they are received. Some appraisals take minutes, while larger, more complex collections can take a few days. Either way, you’ll get a response from us. A clear list or organized photos speed things up. Formal written appraisals for insurance or estates take longer, because every item is documented in detail.

Do you appraise certified coins and paper money?

Yes. Coins certified by PCGS, NGC, ANACS or CAC are valued from their grades and the latest market data for each grade and service, so photos of the labels or a list of certification numbers are often enough. We also appraise world coins, U.S. and world paper money and gold and silver bullion, including bars, so you can have a mixed collection appraised all at once.

Decorative gold separator bar

Free Appraisal for Your Rare Coins and Coin Collections

Email, Text, or Use This Form To Send Us Your Inventory List or Pictures



Upload files of inventory lists and front and back photos of your items.

    We can help build your inventory list. Use the Collection List Maker to photograph your items and we'll build the inventory list for you.

    Decorative gold separator bar

    Professional Associations

    Professional association and grading-service logos including ANA Life Member, PMG, PCGS, NGC, ANACS, CAC, CCE and currency-grading organizations