Best Place to Sell a Coin Collection

Selling a coin collection can feel like a daunting task, whether you’ve just inherited a lifetime’s worth of numismatic treasures, are a seasoned coin collector looking to downsize your holdings, or simply have some old coins you’d like to convert into cash. Finding the right coin buyer is not just about convenience; it’s about securing expertise, ensuring a fair price for coins, and experiencing a truly hassle-free process. That’s precisely where American Rarities stands as your premier partner.

Why American Rarities is the Best Place to Sell Your Coin Collection!

At American Rarities, our long-standing numismatic experience is just the beginning. We’ve built our reputation on three core pillars that ensure you get more money and a superior selling experience for your coin collection.

1. Unmatched Convenience for Every Coin Seller

Finding a local rare coin shop or a reputable coin dealer near you can be challenging in today’s landscape. Many traditional storefronts might operate under pressures that could affect your offer, or they may lack the extensive network of collectors needed to truly maximize the value of your diverse collection.

American Rarities bridges this gap by being both a prominent online presence and a network of physical coin collection buyers nationwide. We don’t just serve a local clientele; we have a national following of avid coin collectors and investors who are actively seeking new material, ensuring a broader market for your entire collection.

Whether you’re looking to sell gold coins, sell silver dollars, or liquidate an entire estate, our flexible options mean you can choose the most comfortable path for you: a discreet, in-person meeting with one of our expert buyers (often local to your area, ready to provide a local coin appraisal) or our secure, convenient mail-in service. We simplify the process to make selling your collection effortless.

2. Get More Money for Your Coin Collection – Guaranteed!

When you choose American Rarities, you’re choosing a path to significantly more money for your coin collection, in a variety of crucial ways:

Sell Your Entire Collection: We believe in purchasing your collection whole. This means you can sell your entire assortment of rare coins, old paper money, and bullion for a mutually agreed-upon price. This is a stark contrast to platforms where you might have to haggle over individual items, or where buyers only “cherry-pick” the most valuable pieces, leaving you with common, harder-to-sell material. We ensure you get full value without the headache of selling piece by piece.
Avoid Hidden Fees & Commissions: Transparency is our promise. If you were considering the auction route (like eBay or HA.com), you’d face substantial auction fees (typically 13% to 22% of the final sale price). With American Rarities, you pay:
- NO Auction Fees
- NO Appraisal Fees: Our expert coin appraisal service is completely free, with no obligation to sell.
- NO Insurance Fees: Your collection is fully insured throughout the entire process, at our expense.
- NO Shipping Fees: For collections over $400, we cover all shipping costs, ensuring a safe and secure transport.
- Check out our article on “What to Avoid When Selling a Coin Collection” for more insights on maximizing your return.

Check our our article on “What to Avoid When Selling a Coin Collection“.

3. Experience the Personal Touch from a Trusted Numismatic Expert

One of the most valued aspects of dealing with American Rarities is the personal touch and genuine expertise we provide. Our extensive network includes experienced numismatists and rare coin experts based nationwide. This means there’s likely a friendly, reputable coin dealer from our team local to you, ready to offer personalized guidance.

You can be confident that when you upload your collection information to us for a coin collection appraisal, your treasures will be handled with the utmost confidentiality, unparalleled expertise, and unwavering confidence that allows us to make you a top dollar offer.

You don’t have to be selling anything just because we appraised your coins. Use us as a pricing resource anytime! We’re always happy to appraise your coins for free, empowering you with accurate information about your collection’s value. We look forward to hearing from you soon!

Always Paying More For Your Rare Coins

Our Simple and Secure Coin Selling Process

Selling your coin collection to American Rarities is designed to be straightforward and stress-free. Our process ensures your items are expertly evaluated and you receive prompt payment.

1. Initial Appraisal (Remote):

Begin by providing us with an inventory list and/or clear pictures of your collection via our online form, email, or text. Our experienced team will review this information to generate a very accurate initial appraisal value and offer. This is your free coin appraisal conducted remotely.

2. Written Offer:

We will promptly provide you with a formal, written offer to purchase your collection based on our expert coin valuation. This offer will clearly outline the estimated value and our buying price.

3. Flexible Selling Options:

To sell your collection, you can choose the method that best suits your comfort and convenience:

- Private In-Person Meeting: Schedule a discreet and confidential meeting with one of our experienced coin buyers at a location convenient for you.
- Secure Mail-In Service: Utilize our 100% no-risk Mail-In Service. We provide detailed instructions and fully insured shipping with active tracking and automatic updates directly to you. This offers a safe and convenient way to sell coins by mail.
- Immediate Payment: Payment is made immediately upon our receipt and verification of your collection. Funds are typically issued via company check, emailed check, ACH/direct deposit, or wire transfer, ensuring you get cash for your coins without delay.

4. Immediate Payment:

Payment is made immediately upon our receipt and verification of your collection. Funds are typically issued via company check, emailed check, ACH/direct deposit, or wire transfer, ensuring you get cash for your coins without delay.

Committed to Trust and Security

Private and Confidential: All in-person meetings are conducted with the utmost discretion and confidentiality.
Fully Insured Shipping: Our mail-in service guarantees that your valuable collection is fully insured from the moment it leaves your hands until it reaches our secure facility.
Active Tracking & Updates: You receive active tracking information and automatic updates for your shipped packages, providing peace of mind.
Zero Deductible: All insurance coverage has no deductible, meaning you are fully protected.

What Customers Say About Selling to American Rarities:

"American Rarities truly is the best place to sell a coin collection.
I was looking for a trustworthy company to handle my father's inherited collection, and their expert appraisal and transparent process exceeded all my expectations.
I received a fair offer and quick payment.
Highly recommend them for selling rare coins!"

Explore American Rarities by State:
Find Your Local Coin Buyer

American Rarities serves collectors and sellers nationwide. While this page details why we are the best place to sell your coin collection generally, we also offer specialized service and expertise in your specific state. Find your local coin buyer and learn more about our services in your area: