Sell Collector Coins

Are you looking to sell collector coins? You’ve come to the right place. American Rarities is the best place to sell collector coins. If you give us just a minute of your time, you’ll quickly see why.

We’ve been buying rare collector coins of all kinds for decades. We consistently beat other coin dealers and coin collecting sites in offering the best prices possible for your valuable rare coin collection.

Always Paying More For Your Collector Coins

Why We’re the Best Place to Sell Collector Coins

Here are three reasons why American Rarities is the best place to sell collector coins:

1. You Can Trust Us
Not everyone is trustworthy, sadly, and that includes rare coin dealers. There have been lots of scams in recent years, to the extent that even state attorneys general have had to step in.

Not to worry, though. We’ve been in business for over thirty years and are a known and trusted name – here are our credentials: 

Needless to say, you’re in good hands with us.

2. You’ll Get More Value With Us
Sure, there are a variety of online coin sites to whom you could sell collector coins to. But aside from the various fees many charge, a lot of them involve anonymous buyers trying to cherry pick the best coins from your collection. On the other hand, we’ll buy your whole collection at once, which is more beneficial for you.

And unlike a local coin shop owner, who may be financially pressured, we’ll never offer you anything less than top dollar for your collection.

3. We Offer A Personal Touch
We do understand why people prefer to sell collector coins locally when possible. That’s we have a nationwide network of coin collector buyers. For special collections, we’ll visit you at your home or office and do an on-the-spot appraisal. If you’re interested in selling, we can complete the transaction right there, and the money will be in your account the same day.

How Can I Sell My Collector Coins?

That’s easy. Just provide us with your inventory of your coin collection (photos and/or an inventory list is fine) via text, email, or the Contact Us page.

We’ll reach out to you with an initial written appraisal. Aside from being free, it’s also IRS-approved, and carries no obligation to sell, so feel free to use us as a resource. At that point, we’ll also make you a competitively priced offer for your coins.

If you accept and ship to us, we’ll insure your coins for free, so there’s no need to worry about anything! After we receive them, you’ll be promptly paid by company check, e-check, ACH, or Wire.

And that’s it! Our process is simple and stress-free! Feel free to reach out to us with any questions! We look forward to hearing from you soon!

Free Appraisal for Your Coins and Coin Collections

Email, Text, or Use This Form To Send Us Your Inventory List or Pictures

Professional Associations