A Trusted Gold Coin Dealer: Sell Your Gold Coins for Top Dollar

A montage of various U.S. gold coins, including a Saint-Gaudens and a Liberty Head, appraised by an expert gold coin dealer.

If you are looking for a reputable gold coin dealer, you need an expert who understands the true value of your holdings. Whether you have classic U.S. gold coins, modern bullion like American Gold Eagles, or a collection of world gold, selling to a specialist is the key to getting the best price.

For over 30 years, American Rarities has been a leading national gold coin dealer. We have the expertise and the network to pay top dollar for your entire collection. This guide explains how to find a reputable dealer and details our simple, secure selling process.

How to Find a Reputable Gold Coin Dealer

Because of how common scams are, it’s important to make sure the online gold coin dealer you’re selling to is reputable. That means looking at their dealer’s track record and reputation.

Here’s what those look like for American Rarities:

  • Track Record — American Rarities has over 3 decades of experience dealing with numismatics and bullion material.
  • Reputation — American Rarities has a well-established reputation for excellence and fairness, with a life membership in the American Numismatic Association and A+ BBB rating.

American Rarities also has a national gold coin dealer network across 50 states which can provide in-person appraisals and offers to purchase. This allows us to offer the local experience you won’t find with other coin sites like Ha.com or StackBowers.

How Can I Sell My Gold Coins? Selling gold coins to us is easy! Just follow these simple steps.

How Can I Sell My Gold Coins?

Selling gold coins to us is easy!

Just follow these simple steps:

  1. Simply provide us with photos and an inventory list of your gold coins. You can send them to us via text, email, or by uploading them on our Contact Us form.
  2. One of our gold coin dealers will respond promptly with a free written appraisal and offer to purchase. For special collections, he may even visit you personally at your home or business for an in-person appraisal. Our appraisals are IRS-approved and carry no obligation to sell to us whatsoever.
  3. If you decide to sell to us, we’ll fully insure the value of your shipment so there is nothing to worry about.
  4. Once we receive your gold coins we’ll immediately pay you via your choice of company check, ACH, or wire transfer.

When you want a gold coin dealer to sell gold coins to, you want American Rarities!

Use the form below for a free appraisal!

Explore Our Expertise & Resources
Learn more about the value in your collection and our unique process with these helpful guides:

  • Selling Bullion vs. Rare Gold? We are expert buyers of both common gold bullion and rare numismatic gold coins. Learn more about our process for buying gold bullion and get a top-dollar offer.
  • Is Your Gold Coin Real? Counterfeit gold coins are a major concern for sellers. Learn how to spot red flags and why professional authentication is essential in our guide to counterfeit coins.
  • Why Do Our Buyers Pay More? Discover the three key reasons—expertise, a large network, and a low-overhead model—that allow us to make stronger offers. Read our guide on why savvy collectors choose American Rarities.

Always Paying More For Your Gold Coins

Hands exchanging rare U.S. gold coins for cash, illustrating the selling process with a trusted gold coin dealer.

Free Appraisal for Your Gold Coins and Coin Collection

Email, Text, or Use This Form To Send Us Your Inventory List or Pictures

Email: staff@americanrarities.com | Phone: 800-622-5680 | Text: 720-600-4740

Professional Associations