Prepare for Your Free Rare Coin Appraisal

Eschenbach 5X loupe beside a real 1875-S trade dollar and 1907 Indian Head cent at true relative size
Free rare coin appraisals nationwide from American Rarities.

If you have a coin you think may be scarce, or a group of certified coins, a little preparation makes your free appraisal faster and more accurate. This page explains what to gather, how to photograph it, what an expert looks at and what you get back.

Our free appraisal is a liquid value appraisal (an offer to buy): what we believe the coin is, how it grades in our opinion and what we would pay for it. It is free, carries no obligation to sell and is usually done within 24 hours, though larger collections may take longer. If so, we’ll let you know.

Decorative gold separator bar

Before the Review

  • List what you have: coin type, date, mint mark, the holder it is in and any questions you have.
  • Do not clean the coin. Cleaning can permanently lower its value.
  • Do not crack open slabs. Leave PCGS, NGC and ANACS holders sealed.
  • Gather records: receipts, auction lot descriptions or certificates. Cover personal details first.
Decorative gold separator bar

Photos That Help Most

NGC-certified 1922 Peace dollar in its holder with an 1858 Seated half dollar and 1904 Liberty double eagle
  1. Front of the coin, filling most of the frame.
  2. Back of the coin, in the same light.
  3. The slab label, with the certification number readable, if the coin is certified.
  4. A close-up of the date, mint mark or suspected variety.

Use soft, even light and avoid filters, editing or heavy compression. Send your photos by text to 720-600-4740, by email to staff@americanrarities.com, or send your appraisal photos through our online form.

Decorative gold separator bar

What an Expert Examines

1928 one dollar silver certificate, 1871 Seated Liberty dollar and 1895 Liberty Head half eagle ready for a rare coin appraisal
  • Authenticity: whether the coin is genuine and unaltered.
  • Grade opinion: wear, strike and surfaces.
  • Surfaces: cleaning, damage, toning and eye appeal.
  • Varieties: recognized die varieties and errors.
  • Market context: what similar coins have been bringing.

Photos have limits. They can hide hairlines, retoning or small alterations, so some coins need to be seen in hand before an opinion is final.

Decorative gold separator bar

Photo Review or Physical Review?

Many coins can be reviewed well from good photos. A physical review is wise when a coin could be very valuable, when authenticity is in question or when photos cannot show the surfaces clearly. You can ship the coin to us fully insured at our expense, or, for larger collections, we can arrange to meet you. See how to arrange an insured physical review.

Decorative gold separator bar

What You Receive

You receive our explained free liquid value appraisal (an offer to buy). There is no obligation to sell. If you decide to sell, we pay immediately by cash, check, ACH or wire; to discuss selling after appraisal, just reply to our message.

Our free appraisal is not a formal valuation for an estate or insurance. If you need one of those, it is a separate, paid discussion; see how to decide which kind of appraisal you need.

Decorative gold separator bar

Rare Coin Appraisal: Quick Answers

Is the rare coin appraisal really free?

Yes. Our appraisal is a free liquid value appraisal, which means an offer to buy, with no obligation to sell. It tells you what we believe the coin is, how it grades in our opinion and what we would pay for it. Appraisals are usually done within 24 hours, though larger collections may take longer, and we will let you know if yours will.

Can you appraise my coin from photos?

Usually, yes. Sharp photos of both sides, the slab label and close-ups of the date, mint mark or variety are enough to identify most coins and give a grade opinion. Some valuable or questionable coins need to be seen in hand before our opinion is final, because subtle cleaning, light wear or alterations can hide in photos. We will tell you if that applies to your coin.

Should I remove my coin from its slab for photos?

No. Leave certified coins in their holders and photograph the slab label too, with the certification number readable. Cracking a slab removes the guaranteed grade and risks scratching the coin, and the cert number lets us look up the coin’s record. Glare on the plastic is the most common photo problem, so tilt the holder slightly and use soft, indirect light.

Is this appraisal suitable for an estate or insurance?

No. Our free appraisal is a liquid value appraisal, an offer to buy. Estate valuations use fair market value as of a set date, and insurance appraisals use retail replacement value, which is higher. Those are separate, paid written appraisals, and we can discuss them with you. IRS-approved written appraisals are available for estates.

Where can I get coins appraised for free near me?

Coin dealers who buy coins, local coin clubs and regional coin shows are the usual places for a free opinion. Many dealers appraise for free because they hope to buy, while clubs and shows offer informal identification. You do not have to go anywhere: send photos to an experienced buyer and you get the same expert review from home. Ours is free, usually done within 24 hours, and comes with a written offer if you want to sell.

Decorative gold separator bar

Free Appraisal for Your Rare Coins and Coin Collections

Email, Text, or Use This Form To Send Us Your Inventory List or Pictures



Upload files of inventory lists and front and back photos of your items.

    We can help build your inventory list. Use the Collection List Maker to photograph your coins and we'll build the inventory list for you.

    Decorative gold separator bar

    Prepare for your appraisal

    How to get a coin appraisal

    What to send and what happens next.

    Free online coin appraisal

    Start the review with photos.

    How to ship for appraisal

    Insured mail-in when you cannot visit.

    Coin collection appraisal

    The full-collection appraisal path.

    Fake $20 gold case study

    Why authentication comes before an offer.

    Professional Associations

    Professional association and grading-service logos including ANA Life Member, PMG, PCGS, NGC, ANACS, CAC, CCE and currency-grading organizations