Sell Key Dates and High-Grade Rare Coins With Expert Review

Actual 1903-O Morgan dollars in PCGS MS63 and MS65 holders, illustrating expert review of grade and certified rare coins

This page is for owners who already know, or strongly suspect, that they have something scarce: a key date, a significant variety, a high-grade certified coin or a coin with a documented history. Coins like these deserve a specialist review before you sell, not a quick counter price.

American Rarities has bought rare coins since 1990 and has purchased over $400 million in coins, paper money and bullion. We are an authorized PCGS, NGC and ANACS dealer.

Decorative gold separator bar

Who This Page Is For

What rare coin buyers look for: 1796 draped bust dollar, 1793 chain cent, 1909-S VDB Lincoln cent and 1899 Morgan dollar
  • Key dates. Low-mintage issues that are scarce in any grade.
  • Condition rarities. Coins that are common in circulated grades but scarce in high grades.
  • Significant varieties. Recognized die varieties and major errors.
  • Documented coins. Certified coins, coins with provenance, or coins from a well-known collection.

Age alone does not make a coin rare. If you have a jar or drawer of old coins and are not sure what they are, start with our page for old coin buyers instead. To learn about famous rarities, see how to recognize famous U.S. rarities.

Decorative gold separator bar

What to Send for a Specialist Review

  • Clear photos of both sides, plus close-ups of the date, mint mark or variety feature.
  • The slab label, if the coin is certified, including the certification number.
  • Provenance and receipts, such as auction lot descriptions or purchase invoices. Cover personal details like your address or account numbers before you send them.

Our guide explains how to prepare a rare coin appraisal step by step. Text photos to 720-600-4740, email staff@americanrarities.com or use the form below.

Decorative gold separator bar

Authenticity and Condition Come First

Valuable coins are the ones most often counterfeited or altered, so authenticity and condition are reviewed before a final offer. A photo review lets us give you a free liquid value appraisal (an offer to buy), but some coins need to be examined in hand before the number is final.

Our free grading opinion is not third-party certification. When certification would help a sale, we can submit a raw coin to PCGS, NGC or ANACS for you. Already certified? See selling PCGS, NGC and ANACS coins.

Decorative gold separator bar

An Explained Specialist Offer

For a rare coin, the offer should explain what we see: the identification, our grade opinion, anything that affects value and how we arrived at the number. If further authentication is sensible, or if a coin might be better suited to auction, we will say so and discuss it with you.

Accept the offer and we pay immediately by cash, check, ACH or wire. Decline it, and if you shipped the coin to us, we return it fully insured. Would you rather keep the sale private? Arrange a discreet collection review.

Decorative gold separator bar

Selling Rare Coins: Quick Answers

How do I know if my coin is a key date?

Key dates are issues with low mintages or low survival rates within a series, such as the 1909-S VDB Lincoln cent, the 1916-D Mercury dime or the 1893-S Morgan dollar. Because key dates are often counterfeited or altered, the mint mark and date need a close look. Send close-up photos of the date and mint mark and we will tell you what you have, for free.

Is your grading opinion the same as certification?

No. Our free grading opinion is our expert view of a coin’s grade. Certification by PCGS, NGC or ANACS is done by those services, which authenticate the coin, grade it and seal it in a holder. As an authorized dealer, we can submit coins for you, and we will tell you honestly whether certification is likely to add enough value to cover the fees.

Do you buy error coins?

Yes. We buy major mint errors and recognized varieties, such as off-center strikes, double strikes, coins struck on the wrong planchet, broadstrikes and listed doubled dies. Many claimed errors turn out to be damage after the coin left the Mint, so send clear close-ups of the feature along with photos of both sides. We will tell you whether it is a true error and what it is worth.

Where is American Rarities located, and is it legitimate?

American Rarities is based in Boulder, Colorado, and has bought rare coins since 1990, purchasing over $400 million in coins, paper money and bullion. We have an A+ rating with the BBB and a 4.7-star Google rating, we are ANA Life Members, and we are an authorized PCGS, NGC and ANACS dealer. We buy nationwide through photo appraisals, insured mail-in and local buyers.

Can I sell just one rare coin?

Yes. We buy single coins as well as whole collections, and a single key date or high-grade coin gets the same specialist review. Do not clean it first, since cleaning can permanently lower its value. Send photos of both sides for a free appraisal; if you accept the offer, we pay immediately by cash, check, ACH or wire.

Decorative gold separator bar

Free Appraisal for Your Coins and Coin Collections

Email, Text, or Use This Form To Send Us Your Inventory List or Pictures



Upload files of inventory lists and front and back photos of your items.

    We can help build your inventory list. Use the Collection List Maker to photograph your items and we'll build the inventory list for you.

    Decorative gold separator bar

    Key-date and high-grade selling pages

    How to sell rare coins

    Specialist review for scarce dates.

    Sell rare U.S. coins

    Key dates and high-grade U.S. coins.

    Sell PCGS, NGC and ANACS coins

    Certified high-grade coins.

    Best place to sell rare coins

    When grade and rarity drive the offer.

    PCGS, NGC and ANACS compared

    Grades that move key-date prices.

    Professional Associations

    Professional association and grading-service logos including ANA Life Member, PMG, PCGS, NGC, ANACS, CAC, CCE and currency-grading organizations