Your Trusted Coin Dealer in Indiana

L. D. Webber Stoves and Hardware LaPorte Indiana copper Civil War store card token dated 1861 with a Liberty head Business Card obverse

Indiana coin dealer buying rare US coins, historical paper money, gold and silver.

Indiana’s money story runs from the State Bank of Indiana and the Bank of the State of Indiana, led by Fort Wayne banker Hugh McCulloch before he became the nation’s first Comptroller of the Currency in 1863, to the Civil War store card tokens issued by Hoosier merchants and the national bank notes of towns from Indianapolis and Fort Wayne to Evansville and Dunkirk.

American Rarities has bought coins, gold and silver bullion and U.S. paper money, including national bank notes, since 1990, with over $400 million purchased.

Whether you are a collector, have inherited a collection or a family’s gold and silver, or have bullion to sell, send us a list or clear photos for a free, no-obligation appraisal. All appraisal requests are reviewed in the order they are received. Some appraisals take minutes, while larger, more complex collections can take a few days. Either way, you’ll get a response from us.

Always Paying More For Your Rare Coins

Hands in white shirt sleeves exchanging cash for rare U.S. coins

Why Hoosier State Sellers Choose American Rarities

From Indianapolis and Fort Wayne to Evansville, South Bend and every small town in between, here is why Indiana sellers choose American Rarities:

Expert Appraisals by Experienced Numismatists:

Our nationwide network has hundreds of years of combined experience in the rare coin market, including Civil War tokens, obsolete bank notes and Indiana national bank notes. We pay more because we know what your coins are worth, whether you sell one coin or an entire inherited collection.

Get Paid Immediately:

Accept our offer and you are paid immediately by cash, check, ACH or wire.

Transparent, Fee-Free Appraisals:

Our appraisals are free, with no hidden costs or obligations. The offer we make is the full amount you receive.

Secure and Discreet Transactions (Protecting Your Privacy):

In-person meetings are private and discreet, and mail-in packages are fully insured and tracked.

Convenient Selling Options Throughout Indiana:

From Indianapolis, Carmel and Fishers to Fort Wayne, Evansville, South Bend and Bloomington, you can meet privately with one of our buyers, and we can meet you at your bank. Or use our mail-in service: packages are fully insured at our expense. We do not provide shipping materials.

Decades of Experience in the Numismatic and Precious Metals Market:

Since 1990 American Rarities has built a reputation as a trusted buyer of rare coins, bullion and U.S. paper money nationwide, with the experience to assess collections of any size and complexity.

Dedicated Service for Indiana Collectors and Inheritors:

We respect the passion of lifelong collectors and the sensitive nature of an inherited collection. We explain what you have and what it is worth, with no pressure to sell.

What a Satisfied Customer Had to Say

“I contacted American Rarities and they were quick to reply. I found them to be professional and courteous. All correspondence with them was answered promptly... overall I was highly satisfied doing business with American Rarities.”— Dank S., Google review

Indiana Numismatic History: Crossroads of America

Indiana’s canals and railroads, its banks, its role in the Civil War and its farms and factories left collectors a rich trail of coins, tokens and paper money:

National Bank Notes of Indiana

During the National Banking Era (1863–1935), banks across Indiana issued their own national bank notes, from Indianapolis, Fort Wayne and Evansville to small towns such as Dunkirk.

Fort Wayne banker Hugh McCulloch, the first Comptroller of the Currency, helped launch the national banking system. Indiana notes are diverse and sought after for their history and local appeal.

Wabash and Erie Canal and Railroad Era

Indiana, the "Crossroads of America," was built on canals, roads and railroads. The Wabash and Erie Canal and the railroads that followed moved trade and people across the state, and some canal and railroad companies issued their own scrip and tokens.

Civil War Tokens and Currency

Indiana sent many soldiers to the Union army, and during the Civil War coin shortage many Indiana merchants issued their own store card tokens, such as those of G.W. Wayland of Jamestown. Greenbacks and fractional currency also circulated widely.

Farm and Factory Money

Indiana's farms and later its steel mills and auto and manufacturing plants kept money moving through the state, and company tokens and scrip from Indiana businesses are collected today.

Local Coin Clubs and Collectors

Indiana has an active collecting community and long-running coin clubs that keep interest in numismatics strong and preserve the state's monetary history.

How to Sell Coins & Paper Money in Indiana

Hoosier sellers can start with a free appraisal by text, email or form. Send photos to 720-600-4740, email staff@americanrarities.com or use the form below.

We buy coins, currency and gold in Indianapolis and nearby Avon, Carmel and Fishers, in Fort Wayne, in Hammond and Northwest Indiana, and in Evansville and South Bend. Mail your items fully insured at our expense, or for larger collections we can meet you at your bank, and get paid immediately by cash, check, ACH or wire.

Indiana Cities and Towns We Serve

Indianapolis, Fort Wayne, Evansville, South Bend, Carmel, Fishers, Bloomington, Hammond, Lafayette, Muncie, Terre Haute, Kokomo and every other city and town in Indiana.

Indiana state flag

Coin Clubs and Numismatic Organizations in Indiana

Indiana collectors can join long-running clubs in Indianapolis and Fort Wayne and attend the annual Indiana State Coin Show. When you are ready to sell what you have collected or inherited, American Rarities is here with an expert appraisal and a strong offer.

Founded in 1939, this non-profit educational club meets monthly in Indianapolis with educational programs and a numismatic auction. Meetings are open to the public, and young collectors are welcome.

Promoting numismatics since 1956, this club serves northeast Indiana and northwest Ohio with monthly meetings and an annual coin show in Fort Wayne.

Other Local Coin Clubs

Many other coin clubs meet throughout Indiana. Find them through the American Numismatic Association (ANA) club directory, and look for the annual Indiana State Coin Show.

Indiana Museums with Money and History Collections

These Indiana museums preserve the state’s history, from pioneer trade and commerce to the documents and currency of its past.

The society's museum and library preserve and share Indiana's history through documents, photographs and other historical collections.

Indiana's official state museum covers the state's history, culture and science, including its economy and industry.

This outdoor living history museum shows 19th-century life in Indiana, including the trade and daily commerce of the frontier.

This museum of Native American and Western art and history explores the cultures of the region, including early trade.

Both sides of the 2002 Indiana state quarter: George Washington on the obverse and a race car and the state outline on the reverse

Coins, Bullion and Paper Money We Buy in Indiana

Selling in Indiana? Learn about Indiana coin and bullion laws and sales tax.

We buy single pieces as well as full collections, estates and hoards from anywhere in Indiana, with special interest in pieces that reflect the state’s history:

All U.S. Coins:

We evaluate every U.S. coin, from early copper cents that circulated in pioneer Indiana and classic silver dollars to modern commemoratives, proof sets and 2002 Indiana state quarters.

Valuable Gold Coins:

We buy all U.S. gold, from early quarter eagles, half eagles and eagles to Liberty Head and Saint-Gaudens double eagles.

Silver Dollars:

We buy Morgan and Peace dollars, widely used across the Midwest, along with Trade dollars, in all grades and varieties.

All Denominations of Rare U.S. Coinage:

We buy half dollars, quarters, dimes, nickels and cents, paying close attention to key dates, mint marks (including “P” for Philadelphia and “D” for Denver, common sources of Indiana’s circulating coins) and recognized varieties.

Error Coins and Die Varieties:

Off-center strikes, broadstrikes, wrong-metal planchets and die varieties can be surprisingly valuable. If a coin looks unusual, send us a photo for a free appraisal.

All Forms of U.S. Paper Money:

We buy all U.S. currency, from early Treasury Notes and Demand Notes to Civil War-era greenbacks and fractional currency, Gold and Silver Certificates and modern Federal Reserve Notes.

National Bank Notes of Indiana:

We buy national bank notes issued by Indiana banks during the National Banking Era (1863–1935), from city banks to small-town banks such as the First National Bank of Dunkirk. We also buy obsolete notes from Indiana’s pre-Civil War banks.

Civil War Tokens, Store Cards and Scrip:

We buy Civil War store card tokens issued by Indiana merchants, such as G.W. Wayland of Jamestown, along with tokens and scrip from Indiana railroads, factories and the Wabash and Erie Canal era.

Gold Bullion:

We buy refined gold bars, rounds and bullion coins such as American Gold Eagles and Canadian Maple Leafs, including fractional sizes.

Silver Bullion:

We buy silver bars, rounds, 90% U.S. silver coins (“junk silver”) and bullion coins such as American Silver Eagles and Canadian Silver Maple Leafs.

Platinum and Palladium Bullion:

We buy platinum and palladium bars, rounds and government-issued bullion coins.

Our Simple 3-Step Appraisal Process for Indiana Sellers

Our process is designed to be fast, easy and stress-free.

Step 1: Send Us Your Inventory
Send photos or an inventory list of your collection by text, email or the contact form on our website.

Step 2: Receive Your Free Written Appraisal
One of our expert appraisers will respond with a free, IRS-approved written appraisal and a no-obligation purchase offer. All appraisal requests are reviewed in the order they are received. Some appraisals take minutes, while larger, more complex collections can take a few days. Either way, you’ll get a response from us.

Step 3: Get Paid Immediately
If you accept our offer, you can use our mail-in service, fully insured at our expense, or we can arrange an in-person meeting for larger collections. As soon as the purchase is complete, we pay you immediately by cash, check, ACH or wire.

Thames Bank of Laurel Indiana one dollar free banking era obsolete bank note from 1854

Ready to Sell Your Indiana Coins, Gold, Silver or Historical Currency?

Contact the Indiana coin buyers at American Rarities for a free appraisal. Email, text or use the form below to send us a list or photos of your coins, gold, silver or currency.

Decorative gold separator bar

Free Appraisal for Your Indiana Coins, Bullion, Currency, and Collections

Email, Text, or Use This Form To Send Us Your Inventory List or Pictures



Upload files of inventory lists and front and back photos of your items.

    We can help build your inventory list. Use the Collection List Maker to photograph your items and we'll build the inventory list for you.

    Decorative gold separator bar

    Professional Associations

    Professional association and grading-service logos including ANA Life Member, PMG, PCGS, NGC, ANACS, CAC, CCE and currency-grading organizations