Find a Trusted Local Coin Dealer for Your Collection

A collection of U.S. and foreign coins ready for appraisal by trusted local coin dealers.

You’ve collected numismatic coins your whole life, painstakingly assembling your treasured collection. But sadly, numismatics just isn’t what it used to be. Younger generations aren’t as interested, meaning it’s less likely your children or grandkids will want to hold onto the collection.

So it’s time to cash in, the only problem is, local coin dealers are hard to find these days. Where there used to be a rare coin shop on every block, now you may be lucky to have even one in your entire area. Also, try and find a coin dealer that has the appreciation and the customer base for all the different types of coins you may have collected. We’ll appraise and make you an offer on your entire collection whether it be U.S. Coin, Foreign coins, or gold and silver bullion. Check out this informative article on Mistakes to Avoid When Selling Coins.

What to Look for in a Reputable Local Coin Dealer

A professional coin dealer should offer more than just a quick sale. Here are the key qualities of a top-tier dealer:

  • A Verifiable Reputation: A trusted dealer will have a long history of positive reviews and professional accreditations.

  • A Transparent, No-Fee Process: You should never be charged for an appraisal, shipping, or insurance. Be wary of auction sites that take a large commission (often 13-22%) from your final sale price.

  • Expertise in All Coins: A true expert will evaluate your entire collection, from common bullion to rare world coins, not just “cherry-pick” the best items.

Always Paying More For Your Rare Coins

Get Top Dollar for your rare coins with no auction fees

Unlike sites like ebay or davidlawrence.com, you won’t pay auction fees with us. That’s important, because those range between 13% to 22%. That’s a huge savings that you won’t find elsewhere.

You also won’t pay:

  • Appraisal fees (some local coin dealers may charge this)
  • Insurance fees
  • Shipping fees ( free shipping if your collection value is $400 or more)

Getting A Free Appraisal and Offer for your rare coins is a simple 3 step process

Gold and silver coins that our local coin dealers purchase.
Local Coin Dealers

Get a Free Initial Appraisal: Selling to us is easy and comfortable. When you upload photos, or inventory list of your collection to us, one of our local coin dealers will get back to you promptly with a free written appraisal value and offer to purchase. For better collections, we’ll even send someone to your home for an on-the-spot free appraisal.

Choose Your Selling Option: Use our convenient and fully insured mail-in service (we cover all costs), or for larger collections, we can arrange for a local representative to meet you. 

Get Paid Immediately: If you accept our offer, we make the sale as stress-free as possible. You can drop off the collection to one of our nationwide network dealers, or if the coins are shipped, not only do we insure the shipment free-of-charge, payment is immediate upon the check in of your items. When you search for “local coin dealers”, you want to find us.

Free Appraisal for Your Coins and Coin Collections

Email, Text, or Use This Form To Send Us Your Inventory List or Pictures

Email: staff@americanrarities.com | Phone: 800-622-5680 | Text: 720-600-4740

Professional Associations