Real or Fake? A Guide to Spotting Counterfeit Error Coins
In the world of rare coins, the most exciting-looking pieces can also be the most deceptive. We often receive inquiries about dramatic “error coins” that, upon expert review, turn out to be sophisticated counterfeits designed to fool collectors.
A perfect case study is this 1802 Draped Bust Half Dollar that was presented to us. At first glance, it appears to be a rare and dramatic “double struck” mint error. The doubling is obvious and impressive. However, this coin is a counterfeit.
## The Danger of “Too Good to Be True” Coins
Counterfeiters often target rare and valuable coins, creating fakes that mimic famous errors or key dates. While a genuine 1802 double struck half dollar would be an incredible rarity, this example had several red flags for our experts, including incorrect weight and “mushy” details that are inconsistent with genuine coins from this era.
To an untrained eye, it looks like a potential treasure. To a professional, it’s a dangerous trap that could cost an unsuspecting buyer thousands.
## Why Professional Authentication is Non-Negotiable
If you have a coin that looks unusual—whether it’s an apparent error, a key date, or a rare type—you cannot rely on online pictures or your own eyes to determine if it’s real. Counterfeits are becoming more advanced every year, and the only way to be certain is through professional authentication.
An expert evaluation will verify a coin’s:
-
Authenticity: Is it a genuine coin struck by the U.S. Mint?
-
Condition: Has it been damaged, altered, or cleaned?
-
Value: What is its true, fair market value?
## Don’t Get Fooled. Get an Expert Opinion.
Before you celebrate a potential discovery or try to sell a coin, let our team of experts verify it for you. We can identify both genuine rarities and deceptive fakes, giving you the certainty you need.
Our evaluation process is free, confidential, and comes with no obligation. Protect yourself and find out the truth about your collection.
Here is a link to a deeper dive into Error Coins and Variety Coins
