American Rarities Reviews: Testimonials From Our Customers
What sets American Rarities apart is that we’re real coin dealers. We have been buying rare coins, paper money and bullion since 1990, with over $350 million purchased, and our staff works hard to make a strong offer on every collection. But don’t just take our word for it: read what some of our satisfied clients have to say about their experience with us, and then judge for yourself.
Want more American Rarities reviews? See our Google reviews (rated 4.7 stars), our Better Business Bureau profile (A+ rating) and the customer stories and reviews further down this page.
What Our Customers Say
“Thank you so much for your attention and follow up during this entire procedure, always putting the customer first and making me feel secure and confident. Your company is a five star operation. Thank you again.”
– Kenneth Kamermayer
“Very professional, a pleasure to work with… your service was A+.”
– Richard Harr, HI
“We must say our experience with your employees (on the phone and in-person) was nicer than we expected it to be. We felt at ease and confident that we were dealing with professionals who had no hidden agendas. Thank you for your great service!”
– Al & Joanne Schluth, PA
“Your customer service was prompt and satisfactory. The questions I asked were answered & explained. I wondered how much I would receive for a bunch of gold coins I started collecting in 1985. The amount was a surprise! I feel good about the transaction.”
– Eugene Kenny, CO
“Excellent personal attention. Good advice and appreciated recommendations. I will call again with remaining collection.”
– Dr. Walter Delph, NY
“I was impressed with the professional manner that your buyer presented on arrival and during evaluation.”
– Dwight Boe, CO
“We recently had a visit from David Weinstein who looked over my collection. I felt that he was extremely honest with me and very helpful in advising. If I were to sell more coins, Dave would be my first choice. Thank you for one of my few good experiences with coins.”
– Joel Likins, OH
“Great to deal with – your buyer took time to answer and to help me decide what to sell… and what to hold. I would not hesitate to do future selling or buying with your firm.”
– Wharton Tiers, NY
“I was pleased with the professional manner in which your buyer arrived on time. He exerted no pressure to sell. He took the time to examine everything I offered, and made me feel a sense of trust.”
– Al Cipra, OH
“In June one of your buyers, Lee Block, came to look over my collection (of coins), To tell the truth, I almost cancelled our meeting, as at that time, I felt it would be a waste of time. Boy, was I wrong! The few hours Lee and I spent together were the best time I’ve had in a good long time.
I learned a lot – thank you for teaching me so much. The best part came at the end, when Lee gave me a check for several thousand dollars! I almost fell down! I thank American Rarities for having the great staff they have. After Lee left me, he went to see my friend where he was asked to give prices on three collections. Lee made my friend very happy. My friend stopped by the next day and told me about the great deal Lee gave him.
When you deal with an honest company that has great people, you just can’t go wrong. Thank you for taking the time to see me and my friend.”
– Ronald E. May, NJ
Please leave your positive feedback on one of the following online review sites, or any others where you may find us:
Featured Customer Stories
These customers shared longer stories. Each card links to the full letter.
“I Knew He Was the Person to Handle My Coins”
“After talking with Lee on the phone, I knew he was the person to handle my coins.”
– Robert Blum, Shelton, WA
Earning a Collector’s Respect in MA
“He is a true coin guy that has similar respect for coinage as I do.”
– Dick Fuller, Auburn, MA
“Nothing to Express Except Praise” for Our Service
“He had all the required information for the visit not only in his bags, computer, scales and reference information but even a hand truck to take the coins away.”
– Frank and Doris McCafferty, Hatboro, PA
The Story of “My Dad’s Coins”
“I sold it to American Rarities after getting two other bids. They came in a bit higher and frankly were more enthusiastic about my coins.”
– Inherited collection seller (unsigned)
Going the Extra Mile for a Fair Market Value
“He called on other resources to derive fair market values since these items are not listed in the coin dealers' Grey Sheets.”
– Thomas G., Sandy Springs, GA
A Fair & Efficient Home Visit
“He made me a very fair offer, which was accepted and completed all in that one visit. Payment was also made at that time.”
– Floyd A., Queen Creek, AZ
“A Very Pleasant Experience” from a Seller in Arizona
“He was very thorough and I was very happy with the price he gave me.”
– Eileen Werner, Benson, AZ
An “Expensive Lesson in Grading” and a Satisfying Sale
“I appreciate his patience in explaining PVC effects and the low end of things (culls). Still satisfied with the sale.”
– Tom R., Las Cruces, NM
A Collector’s Lesson: “Not All Grading Companies Are Created Equal”
“Your man tried to be as helpful as possible.”
– Charles W., Belvidere, IL
A “No Pressure” Selling Experience
“It was nice not having to deal with high pressure tactics.”
– Don Fox
“A Pure Pleasure to Deal With”
“I have had the pleasure of encountering you late in the day ~ but.... […] this shall prove just the beginning of a long and mutually rewarding relationship.”
– Helena
“Most Impressed with His Diligent Efforts”
“My sister and I were most impressed with Ryan and his diligent efforts in the valuation of dad's coin collection.”
– Richard P
A Trusted Coin Dealer in Colorado
“I have entered your information into my collection of local suppliers and will pass your name on to appropriate clients.”
– Ron R., Boulder, CO
More Customer Reviews by Region
More letters from sellers across the country, grouped by region. Each review is quoted as the customer wrote it.
Northeast and Mid-Atlantic
“I was very nervous about dealing with a coin dealer, but you made me comfortable by coming to my home, wiring the funds and taking the time to go through the valuation process. Lee Block represented your company excellently, and I would give you a positive reference anytime.”
– Dick Toro, Bridgewater, NJ
“I was very pleased with Numismatic Specialist Mr. Lee Block in the way that he handled both my collection and myself. He did not work under ideal conditions and is a true professional for that. I hope and look forward to doing business with you in the future.”
– Mark Linscott, Lowell, MA
“My experience was very positive. All contacts were courteous and professional (and occurred as promised). Thank you for following up.”
– Mike Stoholski
“I have been very pleased with my coin selling experience with Dave Weinstein. He is easy going in the negotiation process and has been fair in his pricing quotes. I would certainly recommend Dave to any of my friends.”
– Joseph Miko, Severna Park, MD
Southeast
“Lee Block is hard working, fair, and a very knowledgeable numismatist. I realize that I did not get the value that I wanted, however, you are buying wholesale and I understand how it works. Considering these facts, I think it was OK – but Lee is a super guy and I would deal with him again – and hope to.”
– Ron W., Boynton Beach, FL
“My experience with Lee was outstanding. He put in a very long day with me and I think, in view of what has happened to coin prices in last 3 or 4 years, he gave me a fair price. I will do business with him again when I need to.”
– A seller in Florida (letter to Warren, unsigned)
“My experiences with American Rarities was always a satisfying dialogue toward a continuing educational experience for me. No matter what coin questions I asked, your representatives' responses was always quick, thorough and timely. If the buyer or staff member noticed that I was perplexed over the business end he would initiate inquiry into my body language until I understood the business of buying/selling coins.”
– Ray Silvia, Venice, FL
“Lee Block was a professional gentleman. Made us feel at ease, and explained all facets of the transaction.”
– Norman B., Beverly Hills, FL
“I enjoyed working with Hank. I thought the price he paid was fair. If I were ever to get back into rare coin collecting, then I would call you.”
– Harrison Kinbrell, SC
“My Experience with “Hank” was comfortable and professional. Hank is very consistent. The timing of setting up a meeting was a bit hectic. The result was excellent. Thank you for a great finish to my coin collecting days.”
– Sam Magiera, AL
“David Weinstein was very courteous and professional coin buyer. Although we were not able to do a transaction (with coins), we were very impressed with his knowledge. It was a very positive experience.”
– Mike G., Demopolis, AL
“Thank you for the opportunity to deal with you! You provided a service for me that was not only profitable but also convenient. Your buyer was very friendly and courteous, and the accommodations chosen were great. I will gladly recommend your company to my friends. Thanks again. P.S. Hope David enjoyed his stay in the Birmingham area and in Alabama.”
– Dan Hunter, Hokes Bluff, AL
Midwest
“Lee was very knowledgeable and was very interesting to talk to.”
– Ronald P. Brooks, MN
“Your coin buyer was very professional. I am glad he came to my house to look at the coins. I felt at ease with him, and he answered all my questions promptly and completely. I am satisfied with the transaction.”
– William H., Wayne, MI
“I was pleasantly impressed with the competency, efficiency and integrity of your representative coin buyer, Lee Block. There is always some apprehension when dealing with someone for the first time.”
– Irwin D., Chicago, IL
“Recently, I sold my coin collection to American Rarities. In my dealings with your buyer, he was courteous and helpful. Transactions were complete in a short time – after contacts by telephone, my coins were sold, a check was in the mail and received shortly thereafter. Even though I did not receive as much as I had hoped, I had not considered the drop in the price of silver. I would not hesitate to do business with American Rarities again any time in the future.”
– Bill W., Lenexa, KS
West
“Larry Bristow sounded like a genuine sincere person and I trusted him not to, in plain English, rip me off. His sincerity showed in his voice, which led me to trust him. If I have any more dealings with American Rarities, I will surely contact Larry. Please thank him for me.”
– Millie Poulin, Salem, OR
“I was very satisfied with the services of your buyer, Jim Noffsinger. He was well prepared and equipped to analyze and estimate my coins and paper currency. He was prompt and courteous.”
– Charles Smith, Panorama, CA
“Lee Block was thorough, took good notes and worked hard on my behalf. I am glad to recommend him if I come in contact with coin people in the area. Please relay my thanks for a good job – well done, Lee!”
– Linda M, Red Bluff, CA
“I was thoroughly satisfied with your coin buyer's service. He was most professional, personable, and answered all my questions completely. I will certainly be calling your company when I'm ready to do more business.”
– Ona R., Caldwell, ID
More Kind Words
“Lee Block was punctual, cordial and business like, with mannerisms of an efficient professional. It was a pleasure to have had Lee in my home as a representative of your company.”
– R. Long, Feb 10, 2009
“I thoroughly enjoyed working with Lee Block. He explained the how and why of each coin and paper currency in the collection, and his payment I believe was fair.”
– W Baird, Jr
“Thank you for your response! I really appreciate that you took the time to respond to my text especially since you had no interest in them. I have so many times made the same effort with other businesses to find direct answers not found on the internet. Without ever receiving a return response. So please believe me when I tell you I am very appreciative. Thanks again for sharing your knowledge and including additional information that was of great interest as well as educational. To put it bluntly when it comes to money and personal service YOU ROCK!”
– W. Ott
“Thank you both (Jim Noffsinger and Warren) for being very friendly and appreciated about coins. Also thanks for fair appraisal of my coin collection. You made the transaction very pleasant and very positive experience.”
– Keith & Sue Scott
“Hey guys that's the first time I ever went to a website. I really appreciate that prompt courteous service. Y'all definitely exceeded my expectations I'm an amateur coin collector at this but I'm getting on the right track.”
– Fred Fazio
Why Sellers Trust American Rarities
Our customers mention the same things again and again: a fair offer, clear communication and fast payment. Here is what stands behind those reviews:
- A+ rating from the Better Business Bureau.
- 4.7 stars on Google. Read them on Google.
- ANA Life Members, listed in the American Numismatic Association dealer directory.
- PCGS and NGC authorized dealer and ANACS submission center, with free in-house grading opinions (no slabbing required).
- Founded in 1990: more than 30 years in business, over $350 million purchased and hundreds of years of combined experience.
- Accurate testing with XRF metal analysis and digital microscopy, plus IRS-compliant appraisals for estates.
- Home visits through our nationwide buying network, or fully insured mail-in with no deductible.
- Immediate payment: once you accept an offer, we pay you immediately by cash, check, ACH or wire.
Learn more about our rare coin experts, why collectors choose our buyers, how we handle a large coin collection and what to look for in a trusted coin dealer near you.
Get Your Own Free Appraisal
Join the customers above. Send a few photos or a simple list of what you have and an experienced buyer will reply with a free, no-obligation appraisal. We reply quickly. Timing depends on the size of your list, and we review submissions in the order we receive them. When you accept an offer, we pay you immediately.
- Use the free appraisal form below or our online appraisal page
- Text photos to 720-600-4740
- Email staff@americanrarities.com
We buy rare U.S. coins, gold and silver, paper money and whole collections, with free or discounted shipping on selected collections.
American Rarities Reviews: Quick Answers
Where can I read more American Rarities reviews?
On Google, where we are rated 4.7 stars, on our BBB profile (A+ rating) and in the customer stories on this page.
How do I leave a review for American Rarities?
Post your feedback on Google Reviews or the Better Business Bureau. Thank you for taking the time.
Can a buyer visit my home like the customers describe?
Yes. We offer home visits through our nationwide buying network, or fully insured mail-in with no deductible, and we pay you immediately by cash, check, ACH or wire.