Your Trusted Coin Dealer in Minneapolis & St. Paul

You can spend all day looking for a brick-and-mortar Minneapolis coin shop. We have buyers in your area, ready to appraise your collection.

If you have a coin collection to sell in the Minneapolis or St. Paul area, finding a trustworthy local buyer can be a challenge. Many traditional coin shops are facing financial struggles, making it difficult for them to pay a fair price, and they may lack the expertise to accurately value specialized items like junk silver coins to error and variety coins.

American Rarities provides a better solution. As a leading Minneapolis coin dealer, we have local experts in your area ready to provide a top-dollar offer for your collection. We combine the trust of a local business with the pricing power of a national firm.

Always Paying More For Your Rare Coins

Hands exchanging cash for rare coins, showing the result of a successful rare coin appraisal and sale.

The American Rarities Advantage Over a Local Coin Shop

Many local coin shops are faced with high overhead costs for their retail storefronts. This often means they simply cannot afford to make a competitive offer on your collection. We do things differently.

  • A Wealth of Experience — American Rarities has been in business for over 30 years, purchasing and selling over $400 million in numismatic and bullion material since 1990.
  • Integrity — We have a long history of dealing fairly with numismatic enthusiasts. Whether it’s our strong testimonials, A+ rating from the Better Business Bureau, five-star Google reviews, or lifetime membership American Numismatic Association, everyone can see we are highly reputable.
  • Top Prices — Because of our nationwide network of reputable and experienced buyers, we can pay more for your hard-earned collection than any other Minneapolis coin dealer you’ll find.

Additional considerations when looking for a good Minneapolis coin dealer are transaction and appraisal costs. With American Rarities, you pay no fees on transactions and appraisals are free. Best of all, payment is immediate upon acceptance of our competitive, no-hassle offer to buy.

Top Market Prices

Our nationwide network of collectors creates high demand for quality material. Unlike a local shop, we can leverage this network to pay more for your hard-earned collection. Best of all, our appraisals are always free, with no hidden fees.

Coin Dealers Near You

Unlike other online coin dealers like cashforcoins or eBay, and local coin shops, we offer the convenience of online shopping combined with the trust and familiarity of a local business. Our Minneapolis coin dealer is an expert on Minnesota state laws relating to the purchase and sale of coin and bullion material. He can meet you in person, at your home or business, to make you a free on-the-spot appraisal and offer to buy your collection outright at a fair, mutually agreed-upon price.

How to Get Started

A diverse group of gold, silver, and bronze coins, representing a collection ready for appraisal by a Minneapolis coin dealer.
Our Minneapolis coin dealer provides free appraisals for all types of gold, silver, and bronze coins.

Getting started with us is easy and stress-free.

Here’s how it works:

  1. Simply provide us with your inventory (photos and/or an inventory description is fine) via text, email, or the Contact Us page.
  2. After that, we’ll reach out to you with a free appraisal. Aside from being free, this appraisal is also IRS-approved and carries no obligation to sell. We’ll even grade your coins for free, too. For special cases, we’ll send our Minneapolis coin dealer to meet you in person for a physical appraisal. 
  3. If you accept, we’ll insure your coins for free. Once received, we’ll make sure the money is in your account the same day.

If you’re looking for a “coin broker near me,” look no further than American Rarities!

Free Appraisal for Your Coins and Coin Collections

Email, Text, or Use This Form To Send Us Your Inventory List or Pictures

Email: staff@americanrarities.com | Phone: 800-622-5680 | Text: 720-600-4740

Professional Associations