Your Trusted Coin Dealer in New Jersey

1786 New Jersey state copper with a horse head and plow and NOVA CAESAREA on the obverse and a shield with E PLURIBUS UNUM on the reverse

A New Jersey coin dealer buying rare NJ Coppers, colonial currency, gold and silver.

If you’re looking to sell a coin collection in New Jersey, you need an expert buyer who appreciates the Garden State’s rich and foundational numismatic history.

American Rarities offers New Jersey residents a trusted, convenient, and expert service to understand and realize the true worth of their rare coins, precious gold and silver bullion, and historical U.S. paper money, including valuable Colonial-era currency and the iconic New Jersey Copper coinage.

Live in Newark, Jersey City or elsewhere in North Jersey? See our North Jersey collection-sale options.

Our dedicated team of seasoned numismatic professionals, including our local New Jersey buyer, Elliot Coss, provides complimentary, no-obligation evaluations throughout the Garden State. From Bridgewater, Hillsborough and Montclair to Little Falls, Clifton, Woodbridge and the Jersey Shore, we pay more because we know what your coins are worth.

Whether you’re a dedicated coin collector specializing in early American coppers, have inherited a significant collection that includes New Jersey colonial currency or a family’s precious metals, or possess bullion you wish to convert into cash, discover the distinct American Rarities advantage: your reliable partner for a secure and rewarding selling experience in New Jersey.

Begin your journey today by sending us an inventory list and/or clear pictures of your collection for a free coin appraisal! All appraisal requests are reviewed in the order they are received. Some appraisals take minutes, while larger, more complex collections can take a few days. Either way, you’ll get a response from us.

Always Paying More For Your Rare Coins

Hands in white shirt sleeves exchanging cash for rare U.S. coins

Why Choose Us as Your New Jersey Coin Dealer?

When the time comes to sell your valuable numismatic items in New Jersey, choosing a coin dealer with a strong reputation, extensive knowledge, and a commitment to fair transactions is paramount. Here’s why individuals across New Jersey consistently choose American Rarities as their preferred coin buyer and precious metals dealer:

Expert Appraisals by Experienced Numismatists & Local Specialist:

Our nationwide network has hundreds of years of combined experience and includes seasoned numismatic professionals, and we are proud to have local coin dealer, Elliot Coss, on our team.

He possesses a comprehensive understanding of the rare coin market, ensuring accurate and fair evaluations based on current market values and the specific nuances of your collection, including unique New Jersey copper coins and colonial paper money. Whether you’re looking to sell a single rare coin or an entire inherited collection, our experts are here to help, and we pay more because we know what your coins are worth.

Convenient Selling Options Throughout New Jersey:

Whether you reside in Newark, Jersey City, Paterson, Clifton, Montclair, Little Falls, Bridgewater, Hillsborough, Woodbridge, Edison, Trenton, Toms River, Atlantic City, or any other city, town, or coastal community across New Jersey, we offer flexible selling solutions tailored to your convenience.

You can choose the personalized and confidential experience of a private, in-person consultation with our experienced New Jersey coin buyer, Elliot Coss (for larger collections we can meet you at your bank), or opt for the security and ease of our mail-in service, fully insured at our expense. We do not provide shipping materials. We aim to make the process as easy as possible for all New Jersey sellers.

Fast & Secure Payment You Can Trust:

At American Rarities, we understand the importance of prompt and reliable payment. Upon your acceptance of our competitive offer to buy your collection, we pay you immediately by cash, check, ACH or wire, whichever you prefer.

Transparent & Absolutely No-Fee Appraisals:

Our comprehensive appraisal service is provided entirely free of charge, with complete transparency and no hidden costs or obligations. We firmly believe in honest and straightforward transactions, ensuring the offer we present is the full value you’ll receive for your rare coins, gold, or paper money.

Decades of Trusted Experience in the Numismatic & Precious Metals Market:

Since 1990, American Rarities has served the rare coin, bullion, and U.S. paper money market and has established a strong reputation as a trusted leader nationwide, with over $400 million in rare coins and currency purchased.

Our extensive experience ensures we possess the knowledge and expertise to accurately assess collections of any size and complexity.

Secure & Discreet Transactions – Protecting Your Privacy:

Your security and privacy are paramount throughout every transaction. Our private in-person meetings are conducted with the utmost discretion, and our secure mail-in service utilizes fully insured packages with real-time active tracking, providing you with complete peace of mind when you sell your valuable coins.

Dedicated & Attentive Support for New Jersey Collectors & Inheritors:

We recognize the passion of lifelong coin collectors and the often-sensitive nature of handling inherited coin collections. Our team, including numismatist Elliot Coss, is committed to providing respectful, knowledgeable, and attentive support, guiding you through the coin selling process with clarity and understanding.

What a Satisfied New Jersey Seller Had to Say

“The few hours Lee and I spent together were the best time I've had in a good long time. I learned a lot - thank you for teaching me so much... When you deal with an honest company that has great people, you just can't go wrong.”— Ronald M., NJ, customer testimonial

New Jersey Numismatic Connections

New Jersey’s deep history as a colonial state, its pivotal role in the American Revolution, and its industrial development all contribute to a fascinating and diverse numismatic landscape:

New Jersey Copper Coinage (1786-1788):

New Jersey holds a unique place in early American numismatics by issuing its own state copper coinage. These coins, often featuring a horse head and plow (with “Nova Caesarea”) on one side and a shield with “E Pluribus Unum” on the other, were struck from 1786 to 1788 under state authority.

They are highly collectible and represent a direct tie to New Jersey’s post-Revolutionary War efforts to establish a stable currency. If you have these specific early American rare coins to sell, we are expert buyers.

Colonial & Early American Currency:

As one of the original thirteen colonies, New Jersey saw extensive circulation of various forms of colonial paper money (including notes issued by the Province of New Jersey), British coinage, and early U.S. federal issues.

Discoveries of these historic pieces are of great interest to collectors and can be quite valuable for their historical significance and rarity.

National Bank Notes of New Jersey:

During the National Banking Era (1863-1935), numerous banks across New Jersey issued their own distinctive National Bank Notes, like the Union National Bank at Mount Holly $20 shown on this page.

These notes, bearing the names of local New Jersey towns and banks from Newark and Paterson to Trenton and Cape May, are now highly sought-after by paper money buyers and collectors for their historical significance and local appeal.

Revolutionary War & Frontier Currency:

New Jersey was a central theater for many crucial Revolutionary War battles. Currency from this tumultuous period, including Continental Currency and various local issues, would have been prevalent.

Industrial Tokens & Scrip:

New Jersey’s early industrial development (e.g., Paterson as a textile and locomotive hub, canal construction) sometimes led to the issuance of company-specific tokens or scrip for local commerce. These unique pieces of industrial history are collectible.

Proximity to Major Financial Centers:

New Jersey’s close proximity to New York City and Philadelphia, major financial centers since colonial times, meant a constant flow of diverse currency types through the state.

Local Coin Clubs and Collectors:

New Jersey boasts an active community of coin collectors and numerous local coin clubs that foster interest in numismatics and preserve the state’s monetary history.

How to Sell Coins & Paper Money in New Jersey

New Jersey sellers can start with a free appraisal by text, email or form. Send photos to 720-600-4740, email staff@americanrarities.com or use the form below.

We buy New Jersey coins, currency, gold and silver in Bridgewater, Hillsborough and Somerville, in Montclair, Little Falls, Clifton and Paterson, in Woodbridge, Edison and Newark, and in Trenton, Toms River and South Jersey. Mail your items fully insured at our expense, or for larger collections we can meet you at your bank, and get paid immediately by cash, check, ACH or wire.

If a rare coin would do better at auction, we can consign it for you through our auction house partnerships. Read how we helped a nervous seller in New Jersey.

Selling from a neighboring state? See our pages for New York, Pennsylvania, Delaware and Connecticut.

Major Cities & Communities Served Throughout New Jersey

Newark, Jersey City, Paterson, Elizabeth, Trenton, Atlantic City, Edison, Toms River, Hoboken, Morristown, Bridgewater, Hillsborough Township, Princeton, Cherry Hill, and all other cities, towns, and coastal communities across New Jersey.

New Jersey state flag

Numismatic Organizations in New Jersey

For collectors and inheritors in New Jersey looking to delve deeper into the local numismatic community or explore the rich history of money in their state, these organizations offer valuable resources. And when you’re ready to confidently sell the unique items you’ve discovered or inherited, American Rarities is here to provide an expert appraisal and a fair offer.

The primary statewide organization for coin collectors in New Jersey. The GSNA promotes numismatic education and fellowship, and hosts annual conventions and coin shows that draw collectors from across the state.

Serving the Ocean County area, this active club holds regular meetings with discussions, auctions, and guest speakers. They also have a strong Young Numismatists (YN) program.

This club serves the Atlantic County region, promoting numismatics through meetings and events.

This club holds regular meetings for collectors in the state capital region.

This club serves the northern New Jersey area.

Numerous other local coin clubs exist throughout New Jersey. You can often find a comprehensive list via the Garden State Numismatic Association website or the American Numismatic Association (ANA) club directory by searching for clubs in New Jersey.

Museums with Numismatic Interest in New Jersey

For collectors and inheritors in New Jersey looking to delve deeper into the local numismatic community or explore the rich history of money in their state, these museums offer valuable resources. And when you’re ready to confidently sell the unique items you’ve discovered or inherited, American Rarities is here to provide an expert appraisal and a fair offer.

This is one of the oldest continually curated public numismatic collections in the United States, containing about 115,000 items, including coins, paper money, tokens, medals, and decorations from the earliest period to the present. It’s available to the public through exhibitions and by appointment.

While an art and science museum, it has featured exhibitions on “Numismatics: The Art of Coins & Medals,” showcasing numismatic art.

This historic site commemorates the Revolutionary War Battle of Trenton. Its exhibits on 18th-century military and civilian life in New Jersey would likely include displays of period currency and discussions of how soldiers and citizens were paid.

Focused on Paterson’s industrial history, this museum’s exhibits on silk mills, locomotives, and other industries may include examples of company scrip or industrial tokens.

As the state’s official museum, it holds extensive collections related to New Jersey’s history, which would likely include exhibits on its economic development, early banking, and various forms of historical currency that circulated. Facebook.

Local Historical Societies & Museums:

Many towns and counties across New Jersey maintain their own historical societies and museums. These smaller institutions often have unique artifacts related to their local economy, which could include rare local paper money, industrial tokens, or other historical currency. Researching specific local museums in your area of New Jersey is recommended.

Both sides of the 1999 New Jersey state quarter: George Washington on the obverse and Washington crossing the Delaware and "Crossroads of the Revolution" on the reverse

Types of Coins, Bullion, and Paper Money Our New Jersey Coin Buyers Purchase

Selling in New Jersey? Learn about New Jersey coin and bullion laws and sales tax.

We buy single pieces as well as full collections, estates and hoards from anywhere in New Jersey, with special interest in pieces that reflect the Garden State’s colonial, Revolutionary and industrial history:

All U.S. Coins:

Whether you’re a New Jersey coin collector looking to sell early copper cents that circulated through the state’s colonial settlements, classic silver dollars that fueled its growth, or modern commemorative issues and meticulously preserved proof sets and 1999 New Jersey state quarters showing Washington crossing the Delaware, we are eager to evaluate your entire U.S. coin collection.

If you want to sell old coins or get a coin appraisal, we can help.

New Jersey Copper Coinage:

We have a very strong interest in acquiring New Jersey Copper coinage (1786-1788), including the many “Horse Head” die varieties collectors study, in every grade from well-worn to choice.

These incredibly rare and historically significant early American coins are highly sought after by collectors of colonial and early U.S. numismatics. As expert rare coin buyers, we offer specialized appraisals for these unique pieces.

Colonial & Early American Paper Money (New Jersey):

We are keen buyers of colonial paper currency that circulated in New Jersey, particularly any notes specifically issued by the Province or State of New Jersey (e.g., “Proclamation Money” and Revolutionary War-era issues). If you’re looking to sell antique currency, we can provide an expert evaluation.

Valuable Gold Coins:

As active gold coin buyers in New Jersey, we purchase all denominations of U.S. gold coinage, from early eagles, half eagles, and quarter eagles, prized for their historical significance and intrinsic gold content, to later, more widely collected series. We offer a competitive gold coin value.

Silver Dollars:

Looking to sell silver dollars in New Jersey? We purchase all types, including the iconic Morgan and Peace Silver Dollars, which were widely used throughout the Mid-Atlantic and the nation. These large silver coins hold historical significance and attract strong collector interest.

All Denominations of Rare U.S. Coinage:

This encompasses Half Dollars, Quarters, Dimes, Nickels, and Cents. We pay close attention to coins with key dates, significant mint marks (including “P” for Philadelphia, a major source for coinage circulated in New Jersey), and any recognized varieties that can substantially increase their numismatic value.

Error Coins and Die Varieties:

If you possess unique error coins resulting from minting mistakes or coins with distinct die varieties, these can be highly sought after by specialized coin collectors, and we are interested in purchasing them from New Jersey sellers. If you have any unusual-looking rare coins, we encourage you to have them evaluated by our experts for a free coin appraisal.

All Forms of U.S. Paper Money:

As active paper money buyers in New Jersey, we purchase all forms of U.S. currency, from early Treasury Notes and Demand Notes to Civil War-era currency and modern Federal Reserve Notes. If you’re looking to sell old paper money, we can provide an expert currency appraisal.

National Bank Notes of New Jersey:

We hold a particular interest in National Bank Notes issued by banks in New Jersey during the National Banking Era (1863-1935), such as the Union National Bank at Mount Holly $20 brown back shown on this page. These notes are tangible pieces of New Jersey’s financial history and highly collectible for paper money buyers.

Industrial Tokens & Scrip (New Jersey):

We are interested in purchasing historically significant tokens or scrip issued by New Jersey’s early industries, factories (e.g., Paterson mills), and transportation networks (e.g., canal companies). These local issues offer a fascinating glimpse into New Jersey’s economic past.

Foreign Coins from Colonial & Maritime Trade:

Due to New Jersey’s early colonial history and port activity, we are also interested in foreign coins (e.g., Spanish Reales, British coinage, various European issues) that may have circulated through trade.

Gold Bullion:

Including refined bars, cast rounds, and internationally recognized gold coins like American Gold Eagles and Canadian Maple Leafs, we are active gold buyers in New Jersey, offering competitive prices based on current market values. If you want to sell gold for cash, we provide a secure process.

Silver Bullion:

Including silver bars, rounds, 90% silver U.S. coins (“junk silver”), and internationally recognized silver coins like American Silver Eagles and Canadian Silver Maples, we are your trusted silver buyers providing a secure and straightforward way to liquidate your precious metal holdings.

Platinum and Palladium Bullion:

We purchase platinum and palladium in various forms, including bars, rounds, and government-issued coins, reflecting the increasing value and industrial importance of these precious metals.

Our Simple 3-Step Appraisal Process for New Jersey Coin Sellers

Our process is designed to be fast, easy and stress-free.

Step 1: Send Us Your Inventory
Send photos or an inventory list of your collection by text, email or the contact form on our website.

Step 2: Receive Your Free Written Appraisal
One of our expert appraisers will respond with a free, IRS-approved written appraisal and a no-obligation purchase offer. All appraisal requests are reviewed in the order they are received. Some appraisals take minutes, while larger, more complex collections can take a few days. Either way, you’ll get a response from us.

Step 3: Get Paid Immediately
If you accept our offer, you can use our mail-in service, fully insured at our expense, or we can arrange an in-person meeting for larger collections. As soon as the purchase is complete, we pay you immediately by cash, check, ACH or wire.

Hoboken Banking and Grazing Company of New Jersey one dollar note from 1828 engraved by Asher B. Durand

Ready to Sell Your New Jersey Coins, Gold, Silver, or Historical Currency?

Contact the New Jersey coin buyers at American Rarities for a free appraisal. Email, text or use the form below to send us a list or photos of your coins, gold, silver or currency.

Decorative gold separator bar

Free Appraisal for Your New Jersey Coins, Bullion, Currency, and Collections

Email, Text, or Use This Form To Send Us Your Inventory List or Pictures



Upload files of inventory lists and front and back photos of your items.

    We can help build your inventory list. Use the Collection List Maker to photograph your items and we'll build the inventory list for you.

    Decorative gold separator bar

    Professional Associations

    Professional association and grading-service logos including ANA Life Member, PMG, PCGS, NGC, ANACS, CAC, CCE and currency-grading organizations