New Jersey Coin Dealer

Mixed US and world coins

Looking for a New Jersey coin dealer?

American Rarities has reputable coin buyers all over the tristate area, including NJ, who are ready and willing to buy your coins at a competitive price.

American Rarities Advantages

Here’s what we can offer that the competition can’t:

  • A wealth of experience — American Rarities has been in business for over 30 years, having bought and sold more than $400 million in numismatic and bullion material since 1990.
  • Integrity — We have a well-established reputation with numismatic enthusiasts for fair-dealing, as our A+ BBB rating, five star Google review, and American Numismatic Association membership attest.
  • Top prices —  Our nationwide network of reputable buyers allow us to pay more for your hard-earned collection than any other New Jersey coin dealer you’ll find.

On top of that, we’ll also offer to buy your entire collection outright for a mutually agreed-upon, fair price.

This is much better than going online to sites like ebay or Stack Bowers, where you may have to deal with anonymous buyers haggling you on individual coins. Also, unlike those sites, we don’t charge auction fees (which can be anywhere from 13% to 22% of the sale!). Dealing with us means more money in your pocket for less time and aggravation.

Always Paying More For Your Rare Coins

Our Stress-Free Selling Process

We have a simple and straightforward process when it comes to selling to us:

  1. Simply text, email, or use the Contact Us form to provide a list or photos of your collection.
  2. One of our knowledgeable and friendly buyers will promptly reach out with a written, IRS-approved appraisal. If you need the collection graded first, we can do that as well. Don’t worry – both the appraisal and grading are on us, and there’s no obligation to sell.
  3. For special cases, our New Jersey coin dealer can meet you where you are to provide a second, on-the-spot appraisal, as well as an offer to buy. 
  4. If you agree to the offer, we’ll pay you as soon as the items are checked in with us.

And that’s it! Pretty simple, right?

Find a New Jersey Coin Dealer Near You!

We have an NJ coin dealer with over 15 years of experience in numismatics, from rare coins to paper currency, to gold and silver. He is an expert in the field and an accredited American Numismatic Association member (#3173448).

Once you deal with us, you’ll understand why American Rarities is the top New Jersey coin dealer around!

Free Appraisal for Your Coins and Coin Collections

Email, Text, or Use This Form To Send Us Your Inventory List or Pictures

Professional Associations