Articles Tagged: Sell Coins

This page is a comprehensive archive for individuals looking to sell coins. It serves as a central hub, linking to valuable resources that guide sellers, such as articles on finding trustworthy buyers and understanding the benefits of selling to a dealer.

By providing content that addresses the seller’s journey, including personal case studies like “Why I Divested From Coins,” the company builds a strong sense of trust and empathy. This strategy positions American Rarities as an understanding and expert partner, encouraging potential clients to confidently choose them for a professional and fair transaction.

Laptop screen showing an 1878-CC Morgan silver dollar, with rolls of quarters and dimes, a folding magnifier and a group of U.S. coins in front
Coins: National Numismatic Collection, Smithsonian Institution (photo by Jaclyn Nash), public domain, via Wikimedia Commons. Laptop: Lenovo ThinkPad T470 photo by NickW1129, CC0. Quarters roll: Chris Woodrich, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons. Dime roll: Junk Silver photo, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons. Folding magnifier: Simon Speed, CC0, via Wikimedia Commons. Composite by American Rarities, CC BY-SA 4.0.

How to Sell Coins Online: A Step-by-Step Guide

How to sell coins online in seven steps: know what you have, leave coins as they are, take photos and make a list, choose a buyer you can verify, get a free appraisal and written offer, ship fully insured or meet in person, and get paid.

Comments Off on How to Sell Coins Online: A Step-by-Step Guide
Hands sealing a cardboard parcel with packing tape
Photo by Meanwell Packaging, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons (File:Sealing a parcel while booking shipping on a laptop.jpg), cropped by American Rarities.

How to Safely Ship High-Value Collections for an Appraisal

How to ship a coin collection safely for an appraisal: when to meet in person instead, making an inventory and photos, packing coins in their holders, double boxing, choosing USPS Registered Mail over FedEx or UPS, declaring value, signatures and tracking, and shipping paper money.

Comments Off on How to Safely Ship High-Value Collections for an Appraisal
Certified Morgan silver dollars in PCGS grading holders
Certified coin slabs: photo by Bruxton, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons (File:Coin slabs.jpg), cropped by American Rarities.

Top 10 Tips for Selling Your Coin Collection

Ten practical tips for selling a coin collection: don’t clean your coins, take an inventory, keep sets intact, know melt value from collector value, get written itemized offers, grade only when it pays, choose an established dealer, don’t let anyone cherry-pick, ship insured or meet in person, and know how you’ll be paid.

Comments Off on Top 10 Tips for Selling Your Coin Collection
A Whitman coin folder, a 1923 silver certificate, an ANACS-certified Peace dollar and coin rolls on cardboard, on a gold background
A “What to Do First” Guide for Professional Organizers and Downsizing Experts, from American Rarities. Whitman Franklin half dollar folder page: photo by Bruxton, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons (File:Franklin half dollar Whitman coin folder first page.jpg). Series 1923 $1 silver certificate: National Numismatic Collection, Smithsonian, image by Godot13 via Wikimedia Commons; public domain design (PD-USGov-money, PD-Art), scan licensed CC BY-SA 4.0 outside the U.S.; background removed. 1925 Peace dollar ANACS MS64 holder: photo by American Rarities. Dime, quarter and dollar coin rolls: cropped from a photo by Protobowladdict, CC BY 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons (File:UscoInrolls.jpg), background removed and rotated. Items cut out and shown at true relative size by American Rarities. Cardboard background: photo by Humusak, CC0, via Wikimedia Commons (File:Cardboard-546867.jpg).

A “What to Do First” Guide for Professional Organizers and Downsizing Experts

A “what to do first” guide for professional organizers, senior move managers, downsizing specialists and estate sale companies who find coins, bullion or paper money while clearing a home: the first hour, where coins hide, quick recognition, chain of custody and an inventory sheet, who can sell, keeping cherry-pickers away, a free appraisal and a printable checklist.

Comments Off on A “What to Do First” Guide for Professional Organizers and Downsizing Experts
A silver bar and a gold bar beside an 1875-S trade dollar, a 1902 $10 Liberty gold coin and an 1849 gold dollar on a walnut tabletop, on a gold background
Tax Implications of Liquidating Bullion vs. Rare Coins in an Estate, a guide from American Rarities. Heraeus 10 oz silver bar: photo by Chi Ho Chan (eric2b01 on Flickr), CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons (File:Heraeus 10 oz 9999 fine silver bar (52202724589).jpg). Credit Suisse 1 oz gold bar: photo by Oleg Volk (olegvolk.net), CC BY 2.5, via Wikimedia Commons (File:Gold1oz.jpg). Backgrounds removed and shown at true relative size by American Rarities. Coin photos: Bibliothèque nationale de France, Département des Monnaies, médailles et antiques (Gallica), public domain, via Wikimedia Commons. Walnut tabletop: “American walnut veneer” scan by Poly Haven, CC0.

Tax Implications of Liquidating Bullion vs. Rare Coins in an Estate

How federal taxes apply when an estate or its heirs sell gold and silver bullion versus rare coins: date-of-death basis, the alternate valuation date, the 28% maximum collectibles rate, automatic long-term treatment, valuation and appraisals, Form 1099-B and Form 8300, estate versus heir sales, state taxes and the records to keep.

Comments Off on Tax Implications of Liquidating Bullion vs. Rare Coins in an Estate
A 1922 gold certificate, a trade dollar, a gold eagle and other old U.S. coins and a Civil War token on a walnut tabletop, on a gold background
What to Do With Old Coins Found in an Estate, a guide from American Rarities. Coin photos: Bibliothèque nationale de France, Département des Monnaies, médailles et antiques (Gallica), public domain, via Wikimedia Commons. Token photos by Stevehayden via Wikimedia Commons, public domain (PD-Coin scan, PD-old). 1922 $10 gold certificate photo by Godot13 (National Numismatic Collection, National Museum of American History) via Wikimedia Commons, licensed CC BY-SA 4.0 (File:US-$10-GC-1922-Fr-1173.jpg); front cropped and placed on a tabletop by American Rarities, and this modified image is shared under CC BY-SA 4.0. Walnut tabletop: “American walnut veneer” scan by Poly Haven, CC0.

What to Do With Old Coins Found in an Estate

Found old coins while settling an estate? What to do first (secure them, do not clean them, keep them together), where to look, how to recognize silver, silver dollars, old cents and nickels, gold and tokens, which finds are common and which deserve a closer look, how to document coins for the executor, and how to get an appraisal and sell.

Comments Off on What to Do With Old Coins Found in an Estate
An inherited coin collection: an open album of U.S. twenty-cent pieces, quarters and half dollars with loose coins, flips, a coin tube and a certified Morgan dollar, on a transparent background
Selling an entire coin collection to a private coin buyer: one firm offer for the whole collection.

How to Sell a Coin Collection: A Step-by-Step Guide to Selling Your Coins

How to sell a coin collection without losing value: take inventory, sort silver, classic rare coins, gold, proof and mint sets, certified coins, paper money and foreign coins, leave coins uncleaned, understand melt and collector value, compare written, itemized offers and avoid common mistakes.

Comments Off on How to Sell a Coin Collection: A Step-by-Step Guide to Selling Your Coins
A 1969 proof set, a 1986 Prestige proof set, a 2019 silver proof set and a 2006 State Quarters proof set on a gold background
How to Sell Proof and Mint Sets, a guide from American Rarities. 1969 proof set photo by Billjones94 via Wikimedia Commons, licensed CC BY-SA 4.0 (File:A 1969 United States Mint Proof Set.jpg); background removed by American Rarities, and this modified image is shared under CC BY-SA 4.0. 1986 Prestige set photo by Leonid.Zolotarev via Wikimedia Commons, CC0 1.0 (File:1986 Prestige Proof Set Front.jpg). 2019 silver proof set and 2006 State Quarters proof set photos by the United States Mint, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons (File:2019 US Mint silver proof set.jpg; File:US quarter proof set.JPG). Backgrounds removed by American Rarities.

How to Sell Proof and Mint Sets: A Step-by-Step Guide to Selling U.S. Mint Sets

How to sell proof and mint sets without losing value: tell proof, mint, Special Mint and Prestige sets apart, find the silver sets, check for no-S proofs and other varieties, keep sets intact, set realistic expectations for modern sets and choose where to sell.

Comments Off on How to Sell Proof and Mint Sets: A Step-by-Step Guide to Selling U.S. Mint Sets
Stack of PCGS MS 65 certified Morgan silver dollar slabs on an inventory list beside a shipping box labeled Insured
© American Rarities. A documented, insured way to sell a certified coin collection.

Mistakes to Avoid When Selling Rare Coins

The most common mistakes people make when selling rare coins, from cleaning coins to accepting the first offer, and how to avoid them.

Comments Off on Mistakes to Avoid When Selling Rare Coins
Three bags of 90% silver coins, stacks of Morgan silver dollars, a loupe and a vintage $20 gold certificate on a desk in a bank vault
A lifetime collection of silver and paper money, ready for a professional appraisal.

A Collector’s Choice: Why I Sold My Coin Collection After 40 Years

Why one longtime collector chose to sell after 40 years of collecting, and lessons on planning a sale with your family in mind.

Comments Off on A Collector’s Choice: Why I Sold My Coin Collection After 40 Years
Stacks of American Silver Eagles with Morgan silver dollars in front on a gold background
Silver Eagles and Morgan dollars.

How to Choose the Best Place to Sell Your Coins

How to choose the best place to sell your coins: comparing pawn shops, local dealers, auctions and national buyers, and what to look for in a buyer.

Comments Off on How to Choose the Best Place to Sell Your Coins
Obverse of a 1907 Indian Head ten dollar gold eagle showing Liberty in a feathered war bonnet with stars and the date 1907, on a gold background
A 1907 Indian Head $10 gold eagle, the kind of rare gold coin private coin buyers purchase outright.

Why Selling to a Private Coin Buyer Is a Smarter Choice

Why selling to a reputable private coin buyer can be a smarter choice than an auction or online marketplace, and how to find the right one.

Comments Off on Why Selling to a Private Coin Buyer Is a Smarter Choice
1893 Columbian half dollar, Isabella quarter and three cent nickel on a gold background
An 1893 Columbian half dollar, Isabella quarter and three cent nickel.

Why a National Buyer May Be Better Than Your Local Coin Dealer

Local coin shop or national buyer? How to compare your options and why a national buyer may offer more for your collection.

Comments Off on Why a National Buyer May Be Better Than Your Local Coin Dealer
Obverse of a circulated 1893-S Morgan silver dollar with original, uncleaned gray surfaces, a key date from the San Francisco Mint
An uncleaned 1893-S Morgan dollar, the key-date coin at the center of this story. Its original surface is part of its value.

The #1 Mistake That Can Destroy Your Coin Collection’s Value

The number one mistake that can destroy a coin collection’s value: cleaning. A cautionary story from our years in the coin business.

Comments Off on The #1 Mistake That Can Destroy Your Coin Collection’s Value
Dealer display case filled with rows of certified Morgan silver dollars in grading holders under the heading How to Find the Best Rare Coin Dealer
How to find the best rare coin dealer: the 5 pillars of a reputable buyer.

How to Find the Best Rare Coin Dealer: 5 Key Steps

Five key steps to find the best rare coin dealer: credentials, experience, transparency and how to compare offers.

Comments Off on How to Find the Best Rare Coin Dealer: 5 Key Steps